MovieChat Forums > The Fugitive (1963) Discussion > Suspension of disbelief

Suspension of disbelief


Mind you, I think this is one of the greatest shows ever produced. Still, a few things come to mind, some have actually been addressed in episodes.

Richard can get away without producing a driver's license with picture or description of himself in jobs requiring him to drive (a relative once said California used to use only thumbprints no pictures way back when, so perhaps we can excuse a picture), but the physical description should match. Where is he getting them, or how is his getting by without ID?

Is he always paid in cash? How can he cash a check made out to his false name with no ID to back it up?

The subject of a Social Security Number does come up in one ep, but why not more often? Easier to work with HR departments then?

He often has to run with no suitcase, clothes, etc. He probably still has no ID, but is able to eventually land another suitcase (and his clothes are often pretty clean for a man with no change or money to launder them).

Without personal effects, what about the hair dye? It wouldn't take long for gray roots to sprout, and he would be more noticeable.

Without going into detail for anybody that has never seen the finale, would Gerard have acted the way he did in the amusement park?

And would Gerard, a local policeman, have been traveling the country for Kimble? As an interstate fugitive wouldn't that fall to the hands of the FBI or other national law enforcement?

Oh well...just some fun thoughts; I still think this show was unbeatable. Would have been nice to see Janssen be able to do Season Five....

reply

I've noticed that Kimble never aged throughout the 4-year run of the series. Whenever his physical description was put out over police radios, he was invariably described as being 35. Now, I suppose that constantly-reapplied black hair dye could account for his not appearing to age over 4 years, but it's a stretch.

reply

Well, on the one hand, the stress of constantly being on the run might have aged him.

On the other hand, he got plenty of exercise and physical work outdoors, and didn't have to put up with Helen's nagging.

reply

Do people in their 30's really age that much over a 4 year period? Maybe 10 years, not 4.

reply

Well, of course, your points are valid. But this is the movie Or this is TV, the land of make believe, not reality. I don't mind these stretches of reality because the show- the plot of the episodes- the acting- was so good.

If it were aired today, they'd have to build more reality into many of the episodes. Nevertheless, the excellence of the show overrides the fact that many of the events are stretches and dated.

reply

A TV show like The Fugitive would never be produced today. Much too expensive. Especially when the networks can get good ratings with the junk that dominates the airwaves today.

reply

When he was finally free, how come he didn't face charges in all the different jurisdictions where he slugged or knocked out cops in a bid to get away?

reply

well the show ended, but in reality, most probably wouldn't press charges because they figured no jury would convict, the costs would be steep, including extradition.

reply

Also, given that he faces the death penalty of captured, slugging a cop would clearly be self defense.

reply

No, I think the rules of self defense are a little different when you are a under arrest and in custody of a sworn law officer.

reply

Forget about it being a different time back then,which it clearly was...Not even in the same universe today!...All these ?? are from a current day perspective which render them null and void for the most part!!

reply

ID with picture on it in 1964.....lol. Sorry, but that really is funny. Drivers licenses didn't start having pictures on them until the late 70s/early 80s, before that they were just a piece of paper with your information on it. School IDs, if the school had them, didn't have pictures, either. The only ID with a picture on it was probably the passport. And you know us Americans, hardly any of us have one. rme

It wasn't until the terrorist attacks, mostly in the form of hijackings, became all the rage did security over IDs come to the fore. Same with working under the table. The jobs he took were dead end jobs that even now are often paid out in cash. You wonder why there is an illegal immigrant problem in our country? It's because too many job creators are willing to pay them cash, at less than market rate, so they don't have to pay as much in taxes.

What do you think about all the smoking indoors and non passengers able to get to the gates at the airport. Heck, you used to be able to go on the plane to say good-bye. Times have changed.

reply

That's part of what makes the show interesting - the improbability that someone hiding in plain sight would elude capture for four years. I think it forces viewers to look at what makes the show really good - David Janssen's haunted journey to both escape capture and find the real killer. A lot of his close calls are plausible, and create tension in the stories. The reactions of people who discover his identity are very fascinating. And the show has that unique early-to-mid 60s black-and-white texture that pulls you into the drama.

reply

1. IDs or Drivers Licenses were very easy to forge or alter then, even up through the 1980s. Most were a preprinted form run through a typewriter with no photo and just name and description.

Cash was the standard form of payment for the kinds of jobs Kimble took. Checks were cashed at nearly all grocery stores with the ID which may have been a fake ID.

Your SSN was whatever you said it was, and false SS cards were also easily made and still are. It was very rare for anyone to check up on them, or even ask for the SS card and if they did send away to check, the response took weeks and so Kimble was probably already gone.

He's not really got a lot of overhead, so whatever he makes goes to the few things needed and traveling.

The hair thing is a bit strange but it looks like he uses the comb-in dye which is pretty easy. My question is why didn't he ever grow moustache or goatee or beard, and try some phony glasses. That would alter appearance more than dye.

Gerard would have realized Kimble was telling the truth a lot sooner than the last episode if you want reality, and would have been digging more into the case. He still would not have let Kimble just hang loose like he did otherwise. And no he would not have travelled as he did as a local cop.



-----
The Eyes of the City are Mine!Mother Pressman / Anguish (1987)

reply

My dad ran a grain elevator. Obviously, the elevator was right on the railroad tracks. Often bums from the railroad cars would come to the elevator looking for handouts or jobs. Sometimes my dad would hire these bums for some menial labor like filling bags or loading. Sometimes they would be good workers and make it through the day and sometimes not. They got paid in cash and there were no questions asked. The company benefited by not needing to pay payroll taxes, worker's comp, etc. And the bums worked cheaper than regular employees. They might have been interstate fugitives, and many were probably petty criminals.

reply

The hair thing is a bit strange but it looks like he uses the comb-in dye which is pretty easy. My question is why didn't he ever grow moustache or goatee or beard, and try some phony glasses. That would alter appearance more than dye.


Facial hair wouldn't have worked with the viewing audience of the era. It was important for Kimble to be well groomed and attractive to the female viewership, which made up a substantial portion of the audience.

reply

Some of those things a smart guy like Kimble conceivably might have been able to get away with in those pre-computer days. And back then someone might more likely hire you for a job based on a handshake.

Things like the apparently flawless hair dye and the suitcases, I can chalk that up to dramatic license. The one thing that sometimes bothers me is that a local police officer in Stafford, which is presumed to not be a very large city, would be chasing around all over the country after Kimble. Gerard's superiors would say it's not worth the limited resources of a local police department. Especially since Kimble's one alleged act of killing would be presumed to be an act of passion, he's not likely as much of a danger to the public as some deranged serial killer.

But I also agree with you that it's still a great show.

What I find interesting is the fact that with any of these old vintage TV shows, even with the best ones you have to suspend a lot of disbelief. In contrast, nowadays the better dramas and the limited cable series shows are smarter in a sense, more realistic and gritty. People demand that from television nowadays. Viewers might be more "sophisticated" today, but I don't think really smarter on the whole.

In the old days, watching TV was an experience of being comfortably entertained. When the invention of TV was still relatively new, the experience of sitting for an hour in your own home watching a half-decent drama enacted in pictures and sound was enough. Nowadays that's not enough.

I'd be the first to agree today's shows (the good ones anyway) are smarter and more challenging and don't require as much suspension of disbelief. But in the old days they did a good job of delivering an entertainment experience of comfort. And there are times when that's exactly what I want, which I watch shows like The Fugitive.

reply

I just caught the episode '2130' in which Girard and Melvyn Douglas try to track down Kimble using a computer to predict the probabilities of his movements, job preferences, etc. I didn't find it the strongest episode by any means, but thought it remarkably prescient in that it anticipated our much less private age today a half century later in which so much of our lives, personal history, etc. is available digitally.

reply

The 1960's was probably the last decade in which one could obtain a job without completing job applications and going through background checks. Society was a lot more trusting back then as most people could be taken at their word. We will never see anything like that decade ever again.

reply

I just watched a "Fugitive" all-day marathon yesterday. My head is definitely spinning. I was a kid when it aired originally, so virtually every epiode was new to me. A modern-day "Fugitive" would HAVE to be much more realistic, but I doubt the basic strong stoytelling could be improved on. And just the aspect of seeing actors on the way up (Ed Asner, James Farentino) and on the way down (Celeste Holm, Gilbert Roland) was a hoot.
Kimble wasn't always employed in a menial capacity; he often revealed his medical knowledge. I almost fell off the couch during the episode he actually worked as a doctor in a hospital, and the head doc was going to hire him as a permanent resident without seeing any credentials outside of Kimble verbal assurances!
May I bone your kipper, Mademoiselle?

reply

Even in today's world, lots of people (adults AND children) in the US simply disappear every day. They all have social security numbers. Why can't they be found? Actually, there was one bizarre case recently of someone who had escaped from prison 48 years ago and didn't get caught until he applied for social security benefits using his own SS number!

reply