MovieChat Forums > Lolita (1962) Discussion > Which Lolita Version do you prefer?

Which Lolita Version do you prefer?


Kubricks or the 90s version?

reply

Both are good

reply

Both are good, but the '62 version has the edge, minus Sellers's out-of-control performance.

reply

'97.

reply

Kubrick, but haven't seen the other. I can't stand Lurch, I mean Jeremy Irons though.

reply

Kubrick's version, although the remake is good too.

reply


Neither version is a particularly good adaptation of the novel, which is too much of a literary construction -- unreliable narrator, puns, linguistic tricks, intertexuality, &c -- to ever really translate in a satisfying way to film.

Kubrick once said that anything that could be written could be filmed. His own version of Lolita proves him wrong. But, taken on their own terms, Kubrick's is the better film.

reply

The best thing about the Jeremy Irons version is that he went on to do a reading for the audiobook... Which is outstanding.

reply