did shane die???

It looked as if he was shot on the left side of his body. His left arm was just hanging there at the end when he road off. Making me think that he was shot in the collarbone shoulder area, which is where all your important sh!t is.

So even though we see him at the top of the hill smiling as Joey shouts to him in the last frame, I still think he died. But what kind of ending is that? Seeing Shane fall off his horse after all that would have been a overly sad ending. This way it was ambiguous, so anyone can make any claim they want.

But I'm a full grown adult that understands human anatomy. Shane died at the end.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Yes, there isn't any prove that shane die but maybe there is some clue.
The fact that we discoverd that shane got shot only when he say goodbye to the boy, can indicate that he knew he will dying, so he breaks up with him before he will finds out that his hero is going to die. also the boy shout two sentences about the shoting, again maybe it's a hint about the importance of this injury.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

"he was shot in the collarbone shoulder area, which is where all your important sh!t is"
lol, no, gut shot or centre of the chest maybe.

1. He's dead. The collarbone shoulder area is home of the subclavian artery and vein, the third and fourth largest in the human body after he aorta and the vena cava. He would have bled out within minutes.
Left arm limp at his side.
The last shot is Shane riding through a graveyard. Hit over the head symbolism.

2. He's not dead. He stays on the horse upright. In dozens, maybe hundreds of movies a character is shot in the shoulder and lives. You have to be hit in the head, the chest or the gut for a mortal shot. A shot in the shoulder in real life would likely kill a person but not in the movies.
The final graveyard shot is merely suggestive of his fate at a later date.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

The fact that he is wounded and bleeding leaves an open field to interpret that he may die shortly afterwards, but that's something for the viewer to decide. However I found in the FAQ section this comment from the IMDB, which so well expresses my own thoughts about this matter, that I'll be just quoting it:

Others circumvent the argument entirely by pointing out that it matters little whether or not Shane dies from his wound. The movie itself is an allegory saying that the gunfighter, like the free range cattle rancher, are dying breeds. The West is being settled, civilized and developed. It's giving way to a new era where the rugged individual was being replaced by families... where peace would prevail and gunfighters no longer had a place.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

I 'm afraid that the implication was that he was dying . We last see him riding through the cemetery, arm hanging limp. Not very subtle .

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Then again , watch the last few shots in slow motion freeze frame. Shane grabs his right shoulder. That would explain his arm hanging limp . He lives!

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Yes he died later. One theme in this film is the myth of the unsettled stranger, the gunfighter living outside of respectable society, no home, no roots, a killer who must always move on after he kills because no one wants him around.

Shane plays a type at the end of it's life cycle, as does Wilson. The Rykers of the West are gone, there is no longer any need for the wandering killers to do what settled people can't do.

Analagous to the Dark Knight trope. A hero, but one that can never be accepted into civilized society because of the terrible but necessary deeds he carries out. Sort of like the scapegoat concept. Lay the sins of the community on Shane, and drive him out, never to return.

reply share

add reply

formatting help