MovieChat Forums > Laura Discussion > Knocking off the classics: Finally watch...

Knocking off the classics: Finally watched 'Laura'!


...it has always been one of my mother's favourite films... For years
she has asked me to watch this one..

Well, i finally sat down and checked it out, and to be honest i was awfully
disappointed.

The ideas for a good film are there, and perhaps it's a case of "nothing
like it had been done at the time, and since then it has all been done
again and again, and in many ways better", but man...

Laura was completely unlikable. The "love" between Laura and Mcpherson
completely unbelievable (though the idea of him falling in love with
the concept of her was interesting, her coming back and suddenly being
on "MARK" terms with him was really rushed and lame.)

The climax of the film was handled rather poorly, from a script perspective.

Why would the Cop put the gun right back in the clock?

Makes no sense, other then for plot purposes.

Have to say of all the classics i've checked out lately, this one
disappointed me the most.

Good supporting cast, though.

reply

I had never heard of this film and so honestly didn't know it was a classic but I have heard very little of Gene Tierney or her films except The Ghost and Mrs Muir. Having watched three of her films recently, I wanted to see another and this one looked great. The first part of the film is exceptional, we have a murder mystery and we are introduced to most of the suspects (I counted five but only three that were reasonable), I love the look and feel of the film. There are a few twists and turns, some surprising revelations and we finally learn the truth. But the fun in this film is the journey itself, the characters, the relationships, the atmosphere.
Now, from a police procedural POV, the cops do a lot of things we would find incredibly odd today. Putting the gun back, gulping down drink after drink during the investigation, sleeping at the crime scene as if he lived there, it's not exactly CSI. Then again, the cops in Basic Instinct were probably even worse.
But Gene Tierney is one of the most compelling actresses I've ever seen. Yes, she is obviously gorgeous but she has a unique quality about her that reminds me of Grace Kelly. I wonder if she worked with Hitchcock. I'll have to find out.
Overall I give Laura 8/10.
I think I'll watch The Razor's Edge next.

reply

I really like old films, but...

Yeah, you've seen "The Wizard of Oz" and "Casablanca", so now you're an expert.

reply