Something about her looks....

She's still beautiful to me, but I hate that she chopped her hair off and has gotten really political. It's like, is her career dying or something?

still so hot

HORSEY REAL WORLD "6" AT BEST.HER TALENT HAS GLOSSED OVER THAT FACT.

I was the only male in any state east of the Mississippi that thought she was profoundly fugly when she first hit the big screen.

Many years later, lots of people are finally seeing how homely she is.

Indeed.

Never found her hot tbh. Shes just another skinny chick with a weird face. I'm more into Kat Dennings

She has always had somewhat of an awkward looking face. Even her body has always been rather weird. She was never fat, just very pear shaped and she is so pale.

She's photogenic, without being beautiful. That's very useful for an actress.

Her large features register really well on film, they draw the eye and put over whatever it is she's trying to tell the audience. And the fact that she has regular features but isn't a great beauty makes her able to play a wide variety of roles; beauties can only play beauties, but Hathaway can play awkward regular girls or ordinary everywoman, or professionals who rely more on their brains than their looks, or somebody's girlfriend, or even, very rarely, a hottie. If you saw "Ocean's 8" (don't bother if you haven't), you'd see that she can play someone very glam and sexy if she wants to.