MovieChat Forums > Mel Brooks Discussion > I never found his films funny.

I never found his films funny.



The American Masters program airing on PBS recently has reminded me that he's not really a comedian. I know that comedy is highly subjective, and a lot of people will strongly disagree with me, but I don't think his films are all that funny, they're more silly than anything else. I always get the feeling his 'direction' is to tell people to clown around in front of the camera and we'll call it a wrap.


reply

Yeah, I think he's extremely overrated. I love intentionally silly comedy (Marx brothers, Monty Python, Naked Gun type spoofs, etc.), but with a lot of gags in his movies it's like there's this huge, flashy arrow pointing to the joke. Nice ideas, hit and miss execution.

reply