MovieChat Forums > George Lucas Discussion > George Lucas: "Superhero movies are cine...

George Lucas: "Superhero movies are cinema"


https://www.darkhorizons.com/george-lucas-on-retirement-superhero-cinema/

Hard to believe but five years ago, filmmaker Martin Scorsese dropped an interview quote that has echoed on for years – by saying that superhero movies are not “cinema”.

In the years since, many writers, directors, and actors have responded – some taking argument with that stance, some agreeing with him. The superhero fans themselves have certainly had stuff to say.

One of his contemporaries is Francis Ford Coppola who dubbed them “despicable” a while back, and now “Star Wars” creator George Lucas has weighed in with his own take.

In a rare interview conducted at Cannes this past week where he was an award recipient, Lucas gave a ten-minute video interview to Brut France and was directly asked about Scorsese not deeming superhero films as cinema. He says:

“Look. Cinema is the art of a moving image. So if the image moves, then it’s cinema. I think Marty has kind of changed his mind a little bit.”

He then goes on to talk about his work with Scorsese on the film foundation which sets out or preserve cinematic works. He explains how he helped pioneer digital photography early, even as others he knew like Spielberg and Scorsese were initially advising him against it and have now come around to it.

In terms of the industry now, he’s not really into movies much these days:

“The stories they’re telling are just old movies. ‘Let’s do a sequel, let’s do another version of this movie’ There’s no original thinking. The big studios, they don’t have an imagination.”

reply

As if Lucas would be an authority on this. Guy revels in being a hack. His crap prequels are in the same boat and aren't cinema either.

Cinema is films with a proper script, director & actors, not a 2 hour action scene like all these shit superhero movies.

reply


Scorsese is old school cinema. Lucas is forward thinking. Just different perspectives. And it's interesting, because Lucas and Scorsese were at film school together, and are good friends.

reply

Yeah, interestingly Lucas, Spielberg, DePalma, Milius, Scorsese & Coppola all emerged at the same time or knew each other at usc. They shaped cinema for the better. Lucas fell victim to cgi and became a fraud but the others stuck to their guns throughout their careers.

reply

Calling Lucas a fraud is hilarious and dead wrong. But you have your viewpoint, and I have mine, where I think he is an innovator and a credit to the film industry.

I won't belabor the point. Let's just leave it at that.

reply

Don't get me wrong, young Lucas imo is the greatest ever visionary to grace cinema. He maybe is the greatest storyteller of all time, seeing since he managed to take that vision of another universe and put it onto film in such a spellbinding way. What he created cannot be put into words. The original star wars trilogy are more than just films.

What happened to him after the original trilogy is very sad. That's what I mean by fraud. He took everything he had and just became everything he was once against.

But no one can take it away from him what he achieved before he went nuts.

reply

Lucas was the lead innovator of CGI, 3D animation, traditional special effects, digital film, and movie sound systems (Dolby and THX), DVD extras, video games and movie merchandising. His former special effects company ILM still dominates Hollywood and has won numerous Oscars.
https://clubjade.net/nine-ways-george-lucas-changed-movies-forever/

We may agree that most films do CGI poorly or rely on it too much.

reply

Cinema these days is whatever you can put out and hype for the least amount of money that will bring in a solid financial return - period. To that end there are trolls and bots all over the internet filling out a pretend society to convince all the rest of us that our societies exist and all that matter.

reply

Imo, superhero movies are all about the special effects. Panoramic views of cities or planets getting destroyed. Some back story about 'this guys plight for good' or 'revenge for a past wrong'. So they were designed for the big screen.

reply