Which actor is a better director? Round 4: Mel Gibson vs. Kevin Costner

Yes. "Crossroads" (the one with Ralph Macchio, Joe Seneca, and Steve Vai, not the Britney Spears one) is one of my Top 3 favorite movies. I watched that one so much that I knew just about every line of dialogue at one time. It also contains what I think is the best depiction of The Devil of all time (portrayed by the late Robert Judd). Just a great, great movie if you're a fanatical guitar player like I am! 😃

Trying to think of some others...I liked "Almost Famous" a lot. I thought "Walk The Line" was OK, but not great... Joaquin Phoenix did a good job portraying Johnny Cash, but Cash was just such a unique personality and talent that I don't think anyone can really fully capture him onscreen. I usually love movies with great soundtracks..."O Brother! Where Art Thou?," "Saturday Night Fever," "Rocky," just to name a few. I love a lot of Pink Floyd's music, but I thought "The Wall" was just too weird for me. But a lot of movies about music artists just don't quite live up to expectations for me. I have a pretty trained ear for music, so I'm a tough critic in that regard. 😃