MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Would my plan to bring back video stores...

Would my plan to bring back video stores work?


Okay, hear me out before you get all judgy.

We know that since streaming has started, we've taken a step back in access in what we could watch. We used to be able to watch any movie we wanted as long as we had a VCR or DVD player. We weren't forced to buy a movie if we wanted to watch it once, we would just rent it.

But now if you have a streaming service like Netflix, we no longer have the option to rent unless it's extremely expensive and only in things like YouTube or your cable service provider. And how long are these rentals even available for? What if I wanted to watch something like "The Handmaid's Tale" where it's only available on Hulu? I'm not going to spend money on another service just to watch one show and keep paying month after month until I've finally finished watching it. Pretty much it's like not being able to play Super Mario on a PlayStation.

So what if we bring video stores back and make those options available now? Same prices as before. None of this rent for $12 business. You could still have your Netflix account without spending money on a completely new streaming service. There could be sections of the video store that would be "Popular on Netflix" or "New on Apple+". Of course there would also be incentives like 2-for-1 deals.

This would especially be great for streaming services that don't own certain content. Contracts expire and movies are taken down every month. In a video store, it would be guaranteed to be there and if it's not in the store, the store could order it for you.

Am I delusional here?

reply

I don't stream movies but have most movie channels through my Cable provider. I like the randomness of Scrolling through the guide & seeing something new. With that said there's something i really miss about walking into a movie rental store. My father started that when i was a kid taking me there & letting me pick out movies. I'd support that kinda business again, happily.

reply

Even if my hypothetical video store happened, it would really only be for hardcore movie fans who like the experience of going out, looking at covers, and meeting other film fans.

reply

Long ago when I'd visit my beloved movie store I'd often run into people from my past. Childhood friends, college buddies & sometimes family members. That was an added bonus to renting & returning all those Dvds

reply

hardcore fans seem to want to own not rent. the physical rental business seems dead for now.

reply

I could always have a rent to own option.

reply

that'd be a nice surprise, you rent the movie for the 3rd time & are told to not return it

reply

Or you rent it once, tell them you want to buy it and pay the difference.

reply

Besides the cost of running a storefront, the studios overcharged video stores for DVDs and videos. A $20 retail DVD would cost the video stores $75 to buy. Then they would rent it for $3 each customer. It's hard to break even.

I wouldn't rent anything for $12. You might as well go the movie theater for that price.

reply

interesting, maybe they gotta discount to buy in bulk

reply

I doubt it.

reply

I never said I was a mathematician.

reply

assets - liabilities = profit or loss

no profit = out of business

reply

IM STARTING TO MISS YOU WHEN YOU ARENT HERE.😣

reply

Marry me and we will never be separate again.

reply

did he say yes ? did he

reply

He left me hanging like a bride leaves the groom at the altar.

reply

wish my ex woulda did that

reply

YES...BUT KNOW THIS...IM PUTTING A BABY IN YOU ONE WAY OR ANOTHER.😏

reply

My video store idea is a $15 monthly fee, you can rent 5 at a time, unlimited.

1000 people a month is $15000, that should cover costs.

reply

I WOULD RENT AT YOUR STORE.📀

reply

That could work.

reply

You'd need a big amount of stock to launch, only problem.

reply

My god so much to dissect
We know that since streaming has started, we've taken a step back in access in what we could watch.
no we havent there is more available than ever before.

We used to be able to watch any movie we wanted as long as we had a VCR or DVD player.
Now you can watch any movie you want on any device you own - phone, smart tv , xbox etc etc

We weren't forced to buy a movie if we wanted to watch it once, we would just rent it.
you arnt forced to now, you get 1000s of movies avalble for the cost of two rentals per month

-----
christ , thats only your first paragraph , i havent got time , im at work
but basically absolutletly everything you said is wrong or nonsensical
Streaming does everything Video store rentals does and a whole lot more
Exept for rewinding tapes and travelling to the store,
but you can replicate that yourself by walking or driving around in circles pointlessly

Am I delusional here?
yes! i resounding yes


reply

no we havent there is more available than ever before.


I said "access", not "available". Those are two different things. I gave the example of "The Handmaiden's Tale" not being available on Netflix. You would have to go outside of Netflix to get the show.

Now you can watch any movie you want on any device you own - phone, smart tv , xbox etc etc


The selection availability for streaming varies depending on who is streaming it. You also can't watch a BluRay that you bought on your phone, unless you use a digital code. But some of those are only available if you have a YouTube account.

you arnt forced to now, you get 1000s of movies avalble for the cost of two rentals per month


Again, you are watching only what is available by the place you are streaming from. Why if only 1/4 of the content is good on Netflix and 1/4 of the content is good on Apple+. You're in for a tough decision. And let's not forget the fact that streaming services drop movies/shows that they don't own all the time.

Streaming does everything Video store rentals does and a whole lot more


Yeah, it even uses GB per film. If you don't have unlimited internet (as well as a good connection) you're not going to have as many options as you think you are. You also don't own anything on streaming.

reply

ok,
Well i can watch Handmaiden on amazon currently - althoug hi take your point - i no longer seem to be able to acces "scrubs" on the UK tv channel that had it on demand.
I'm sure there was stuff video shops just couldnt get though.
also you can rent a stream on amazon for most stuff
and also all the above is just issues with the current crop of streaming services - not the idea in general

i think the above covers your points 2 & 3 too

4) unlimited internet .
yes - you definiately need that
but most people have that 99% of the time

...actuially no - becasue some streaming services have #offline' cache mode thingys
eventualluy they all will - if it turns out theres demand for it

reply

Your an also competing against pirating. Without spending extra people can download for free.A lot of films on YouTube too.

I think you'd need to offer something people can't get at home.

reply

I think it would tap into the nostalgia vibe.

reply

It might and I was thinking of theme nights where people can come in and watch a film together. I know you're thinking - That's a cinema! But no, in a cinema everyone is disconnected. I'm talking about a room with bean bags and couches, people come in perhaps a host chats about the film. Pizza is ordered and they all watch a movie together. Could be like a social club?

You could have dress up nights etc

reply

If it were retro showings of cool cinema I’d be there for sure.

reply

Yeah thats what I'm thinking. In Melbourne Australia there was a cinema that showed Blues Brothers every week and people would turn up in costume, dance in the aisles, actually stand up on the little stage in front of the screen and act out the scenes!

Just that kind of laid back yet silly fun. People are too serious now.

reply

Here where I live a drive in theater has recently opened that plays lots of great older films and it’s really been fun. So yeah, people seem to be embracing retro stuff these days. 👍

reply

It depends on what you mean by "bring back video stores". If you mean, bring them back to their 1980s through mid 2000s level of ubiquity/success, then I don't think that's even remotely plausible. However, they are still viable on some level, because some video rental stores still exist. Here's one example:

https://beyondvideo.org/

There's also one Blockbuster Video store left in the world, in Bend, Oregon:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockbuster_(Bend,_Oregon)

I'm nostalgic about going to the video store when I was a kid in the '80s, but I'm not nostalgic in a way that makes me wish I could still do it now. Well, I'd jump at the chance to time travel back to the '80s and do it again, but I'm not interested in doing it in the present. I feel the same way about arcades. I loved them as a kid, and I still like playing my favorite games from when I was a kid, but even if arcades were still a common thing, I wouldn't bother going to one. I do have four of my favorite arcade machines here at home though, and I can also play all of the ones I ever played as a kid, on MAME.

Watching a movie at home isn't a big deal anymore like it was in the '80s, when most people only had three TV channels, and VCRs were still quite expensive. It was more than worth the effort back then to go to the video store, and then go back the next day to return your rental(s). Also, my best friends Corey and Tom were an integral part of the whole movie watching and rental experience, and they're long gone now. Corey was killed in Afghanistan and Tom lives in a different state. Even if they were still around it still wouldn't be the same, because we're not kids anymore, obviously.

reply

I agree with you that watching a movie at home isn't a big deal anymore. I miss the excitement of a movie being available and couldn't wait coming home to watch it. Now I can watch so many at home without leaving the house.

My video store would need gimmicks for people to show up. I would need to make searching for a film a fun experience.

reply