Thoughts on this


I've been wary of anything being "remade" in this day and age ever since the "Woke Era" started, because basically almost anything Hollyweird touches these days turns to crap.

Such feelings didn't abate when Nerdrotic and Midnight's Edge brought up the first photos and trailers for this show. They said it looked like a lousy cosplay convention, rather than a proper tv show, and I can see why they said that.

I recall a film that came out around the Millennium that gave me the same bad vibes as this does. It was "Dungeons and Dragons," which came out in 2000 https://moviechat.org/tt0190374/Dungeons-and-Dragons It was pretty much a B-grade flick that could be considered "woke" by today's standards. It had crappy writing, bad acting, diverse characters, cheap costumes and cartoony CGI, a cliched, predictable storyline, and black elves. It was forgotten by the majority of people who watched it less than 5 years after it came out (save for the few fantasy geeks who were desperate for entertainment at the time). None of the actors involved did anything noteworthy with their careers, save for Jeremy Irons.

Another vibe I got from this LOTR series was the same bad vibes I got from that "His Dark Materials" tv show the BBC made a few years ago. https://moviechat.org/tt5607976/His-Dark-Materials It looked like a cheap, crappily made version of of the 2007 "Golden Compass" film, and I was not impressed with what little I saw. You notice nobody talks about this show nowadays, and it's only been three years. It was just that memorable. [It also unfortunately exposed how shitty Phillip Pullman's writing got after his first book, sad to say.]

So yeah. It's gonna be so woke that I think it's gonna be the biggest Hollyweird dumpster fire of 2022. I'll happily miss this and go back to watching the Peter Jackson films, which are 100x better.

reply

seems lame as shit

reply

There is only a 1m announce on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhqGCPMfkNM
A new age begins September 2, 2022. Journey to Middle-earth with The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
First look with several images: https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2022/02/amazon-the-rings-of-power-series-first-look
The teaser is not released until Sun eve: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twPNrTT4nnk

I'm not going to watch youtoob troll shit. Here is a legit fan channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/NerdoftheRings

reply

I hope you like black female dwarves with no beards and gigantic nuclear explosions on their heads, ugly, flat-chested Galadriel in cheap, silver armor that's leading a bunch of bitchy, man-hating lesbo elves in a war against the patriarchy, and hobbits that never existed. Plenty of "concentual" sex too. Oh yeah, they decided it was 1960s America in the middle of Middle-Earth and stuck a black elf in a "forbidden" relationship with a white human girl. Nice, huh? What's next? A Sauron with a bad blond hairpiece being led by orcs wearing MAGA hats?

reply

I'll give it a shot, but I'm annoyed and very skeptical. They should be working from The Silmarillion instead of making up new stories.

reply

There was originally an expert working with them a few years ago, and he even went on an interview and told the people on whatever tv/radio show it was what could be included and what couldn't be included in a Middle-Earth production. Strangely, he was let go from the production soon after that interview. Coincidence?

reply

Hm… ThatStarWarsGirl says the same thing. You’re not her, are you?


I digress, back to topic. Given the state of today’s entertainment industry, I’m sure this new Middle Earth show on Amazon will be awful, just like a soft reboot that tries to appeal to a new generation of fans while antagonizing many older fans. Star Trek, Star Wars, Charlie Angels, Ghostbusters, 007, list goes on and on…

reply

No, I'm not her. I heard it on YouTube from Nerdrotic's latest "Friday Night Tights."

What's hilarious is, someone commented during that show (it was live with people doing a "super-chat" with the hosts) that if Hollywood thinks angry Star Wars fans are bad, they haven't met angry Tolkien fans yet.

reply

I heard about that, seems like a generally bad attitude on the part of the producers of this crap TV show. It's almost like they were astounded that this old geriatric man (their description) who said exactly what should happen in THEIR TV show inflamed their sensitive egos and they did the equivalent of yell at him and go IT'S OUR FUCKING TV SHOW, WE'LL DO WHAT WE FUCKING WANT, OLD MAN! and sacked him.

Seriously, the arrogance of youth these days, especially over experienced older professionals.

reply

I read they don't have the rights to the Silmarillion, just the back up appendixes from Return of the King. Which is just a sweeping outline of events and the like. Pretty much carte blanche to go nuts making up whatever they please.

reply

That's correct. But I'm sure the Tolkien estate could have been per$uaded to give up the rights and Bezos is certainly rich enough to meet their price.

reply