MovieChat Forums > It Chapter Two (2019) Discussion > Did King realise that the adult half of ...

Did King realise that the adult half of the book was inferior?


Is that why he decided to "interlace" the two time periods together for the book? I find it distracting going back and forth in time when reading the book, but considering that the Losers' encounter with IT as both children and adults unfolds more or less at the same time in the book, going back and forth, then I think King thought it was the only way to maintain interest?

Then again, the book and the miniseries does make a similar mistake when they have them as adults receiving the phone calls that bring their childhoods back to them, which in turn makes the childhood battle with IT pointless as we KNOW they survived.

So King was stuck between a rock and a hard place whichever way he chose. Muschietti separated the time periods, at least for them as children, so for those who never read the book, the suspense was higher and so it was better received in the first Chapter, but then the adult encounter was less interesting in the second half, so Chapter 2 suffered.

So the story can't win, either way... unless people like the adult half, which many do. So it's all down to taste.

reply

If he had realised perhaps he wouldn't have had the adult part or maybe done it as a sequel.

reply

No, I doubt it.

It was the 1990 miniseries that sent the film into a pop culture stratosphere.

And the first part was the only portion of film that people remembered.

And 30 million people watched it that night.

reply

Yeah, if it was split over two nights, that would've been it. I think the BBC showed it that way too.

So it would seem that no matter what attempts are made to adapt the book, the adult portion will always be inferior.

reply

Of course. Because everyone reflects on their childhood.

reply

their adult lives didn't seem realistic either. they've all become wildly successful: a big time author, a stand-up comic, an architect, a highly paid risk analyst, not sure what Betty did but she married some rich jerk. only the guy who stayed in Derry was some kind of conspiracy nut.

It's like having 3 major league pitchers from the same Little League team. It just doesn't happen.

reply

IT gave them good lives so they wouldn't wanna return.

reply