MovieChat Forums > A Quiet Place (2018) Discussion > 3 things that bugged me... (Spoiler Aler...

3 things that bugged me... (Spoiler Alert)


1. Super Market opening scene... So in this world, staying quiet is vital, yet they trust their toddler to run around an abandoned super market, which can be quite messy, chaotic with objects everywhere. You trust your little toddler isn't going to make an accident? When the Dad appears, he even instructs the toddler to go get his mother. And when they leave, the parents walk ahead of the kids! With the toddler being the very last in line! SMH!! So can we really be shocked when this boy is the first victim? They are so careless! BTW, toddler, or 4-6 yrs old, it doesn't matter, the point is he was the youngest.

2. Getting pregnant in this world, really? Okay, maybe this one is explainable. Perhaps, she got pregnant before the "whole thing" happened. Whole thing as in virus outbreak, alien invasion, etc. We don't know what happened.

3. The Nail... although nobody else stepped on it. The nail was never removed, and there wasn't any scene to let us know the mom warned them about it. Even in the end when the three of them went down the same stairs, the camera focused on the nail. Obviously to make the audience nervous and wonder if any of the kids will step on it. You could argue that the family knew about it, and it didn't have to be explained on camera, but due to the continuity of the movie, I didn't see any opportunity for them to have this conversation off screen. If we are to assume that they did have a talk about how she injured her foot, and are aware of the protruding nail, and if the nail is no longer a problem then why zoom in or focus on it? Obviously to scare the audience. But like I said, it's illogical because it would be common sense for this mother to warn her kids. It wouldn't take much to do it also. Since she went down the stairs first, she could point to the nail, do some gesture, etc. But nope, nothing, no warning for her kids. Neither stepped on it, so it was their lucky day, no thanks to the mom. LOL!

Having said that... I enjoyed the movie, it was very tense!

reply

I agree about your #1, they were definitely careless there.

Her getting pregnant bugged me a little bit as well but it is perfectly explainable. It could very well have been unintentional, and once it happened what was the alternative? Trying to perform an abortion is kind of risky when you don't know what you are doing. By the way, it clearly happened AFTER the monsters invaded. The first part (when the youngest boy is killed) takes place on day 89, and the rest of the movie takes place on day 470 or something like that - much longer than nine months.

The nail was not very good writing. I had the impression that the nail wasn't always raised like that, that it happened when her laundry bag got stuck and she pulled it. There are two problems with that: first of all, I don't think it is possible to bend a metal nail with a laundry bag, no matter how hard you pull on it. Second, if you are carrying a bag and it gets stuck on something, even under normal circumstances you wouldn't just keep pulling, you would check why it is stuck and try to free it. That should be doubly true in the world of the movie, where any loud sound can get you killed.

And if the nail had always been like that, then that is also bad writing. The two adults used those stairs regularly and they should have noticed it and fixed it a long time ago!



reply

I also realized the movie started day 89 when they lost the little boy, the fast forward to four hundred something, so that means the pregnancy wasn't before it all started. Which then makes me say maybe in this world, where every little mistake is costly, maybe you don't go on a training expedition near her due date? Few weeks early, few weeks late, it happens all the time, this was the month you stay close to your wife.

reply

and once it happened what was the alternative? Trying to perform an abortion is kind of risky when you don't know what you are doing.

People have been performing self abortions for centuries. And what difference would it make if she messed up her reproductive organs under the circumstances?

reply

"People have been performing self abortions for centuries"? Really? How can you possibly not be aware of how dangerous abortions are when performed by someone who doesn't know what they are doing? In countries where abortion is illegal women die from botched procedures all the time!

reply

People have been performing self abortions for centuries? Really?

Yes, really.
https://prochoice.org/education-and-advocacy/about-abortion/history-of-abortion

reply

How convenient that you neglected to include the crucial part of my post, which is THAT ABORTIONS PERFORMED BY PEOPLE WHO DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING IS A RISKY PROCEDURE!!!!

reply

More risky than being wiped out because the baby cried or less risky?

reply

They lost a child. Sometimes when a couple loses a child, they feel a need to have another one.

reply

That’s what I think

reply

Nah I think its more likely he didn't pull out fast enough.

reply

Only male teenagers think that pulling out is a good way to prevent pregnancy.

reply

In a world without condoms I don't think that would necessarily be the case.

reply

like all horror movies this one had stupid people doing stupid things.....

reply

The more I think about it, the demise of the first boy doesn't make much sense. They trusted him to run around a super market, they trusted him to go "fetch your mother." Which means they've been used to living like this, and the boy has been educated, he knows not to make a sound. He's smart! Then when he had the spaceship in his hands, all of a sudden, you hear this tense music, and the father had to slowly remove the spaceship and remove the batteries as if dismantling a bomb. Why all of a sudden did the boy turn dumb? LOL! And again, they walk ahead of the boy, and the "all of a sudden" dumb boy grabs the batteries and the rest is history.

Tense movie, I enjoyed it. But a lot of the methods to create the tension were contrived.

reply

only because i've seen the movie 3 times i can help. the father kept a eye outside, the mother helped find medicine, the daughter was obviously put in charge of the small boy. he kept running away from her. the mother SHOULD have been at the back of the parade.

reply

What about the corn in the silo? Would that be worse than quicksand and one could drown in it? It could be if the silo was open, but I'm not sure how it became open.

I wasn't sure how the creature got into the sound proof room. Wouldn't it have to move the mattress? As it was walking down the stairs, wouldn't it have stepped on the nail?

While the movie had tension and a good story, the stupid things mentioned made me give it a 7. I'll give it higher if there is an explanation.

reply

The boy stepped on the hatch at the top and fell through. The girl jumped after him. And even in quicksand you can make swimming motions to "swim" in it. But maybe it was the panic…

The mattress thing is what annoyed me as well. You see the father putting the mattress back and next thing is the creature down below. How?

reply

Ok, I looked up how people have died in silos and have moved the film up to 7.5. I didn't see all of the movie as clearly in an indoor theater. I saw it at a drive-in. The setting seemed darker, and I probably missed the hatch part or didn't remember it. Also, there was other noise all around which may not have been so at an indoor theater. My loss.

reply

google people dying in silo's. it happens. quicksand isn't as bad as movies show.

reply

Exactly. I thought as much but it was effective little piece.

reply

Just like in zombie movies, I'm looking at you Walking Dead, I don't understand women getting pregnant. It's a new scary world, maybe hold off for a while. But the birth and then caring for a baby in this silent world makes for great tension and horror.

As for the nail, as they are all walking down the stairs, you see Emily Blunt give them a look with her head pointing to the nail to let them know to look out.

reply

Getting pregnant in their situation is beyond careless. You know full well that an infant will almost certainly get your entire family killed, and it isn't like they couldn't acquire some birth control. They clearly can scavenge stores and condoms are both plentiful and extremely low priority for most, so there should be an ample supply.

reply

I'm sorry, but if I was with John Krasinski id be getting knocked up left and right!

reply

He'd just do anal on you. You up for nothing but anal for the rest of your life?

reply

I actually saw the getting pregnant as part of them trying to live a normal life or trying to live positively as if this situation would be over soon. There were several other scenes that illustrate this like the boy being basically homeschooled and learning things like mathematics. It seemed very much like they were trying to be as "normal" and hopeful as possible.

reply

I'm probably wrong here, but I got the feeling they were a religious family (mormon or something, obviously farmers so maybe the bible belt) so maybe that's why they didn't use protection or try to abort. Remember they prayed at the dinner table.

reply

In relation to point 2... Survival of the species dude... That's what humans have done for centuries after disasters, wars and plagues in order to get to our generation...

On point 3, the nail... The mother indicated to the children about the nails as she led them down the stairs... The nail wasn't always exposed, it got into that position when it was caught on the laundry bag...

Don't let the minutia of horror movies spoil the experience for you... You'll have more fun 😎

reply

I missed that... I did not see the mother warning or gesturing to the kids about the nail. Maybe it was very subtle.

reply

In relation to point 2... Survival of the species dude... That's what humans have done for centuries after disasters, wars and plagues in order to get to our generation...

Bringing a noisy newborn into a world where noise is a death sentence sounds like the exact opposite of survival of the species.

reply

Not breading ensures extinction... 😉

Anyway, the whole movie is about the anxiety of parenting and the complex emotions, behaviours and ideas that come from it... The superhearing, blind aliens are just a genre gimmick for the story to work as a bit of horror entertainment... 😎

You could get rid of the aliens and make it a drama about a family who has retreated into suburbia to raise their children in safety, they lose a child in an avoidable accident, become helicopter parents as a result... and as the movie progresses they keep their love and family together against the odds, have a new baby and learn to manage their anxiety while protecting their offspring by enabling their kids to cope with life as opposed to simply being overwhelmed by it... It would probably not make money and not be as thrilling, but that's what the aliens and horror are for 😉

This is a movie about parenting, giving birth matters... It raises the question, dramatically through alien threat, of 'would you bring a new life into just an ugly and dangerous world?' ... This is a question, every committed couple has asked themselves at some point... that's the thematic reason for having the birth in the movie...

I understand where you are coming from, but this is not a survivalist, how-to make it out alive type movie... Where the problem of making it to the next day is 'solved'... It's not 'The Martian'...

reply

Not breading ensures extinction...

They already had 2 offspring to take care of that problem.

"...but this is not a survivalist, how-to make it out alive type movie... "

That's exactly what it is. The situations are too contrived to make it a convincing straight drama or character study.

reply

I saw it as a metaphor for contemporary parenting... I guess we just see the movie differently...

reply

-Agreed about number one, they were really careless with heir kids at the market.

-The second one while stupid i kind of understand, they just lost a child and I assume the pregnancy was an accident and they wouldn't want to abort.

-About the nail, If i remember correctly the mom pointed to the nail when they were reunited so that the kids would not step on it.

reply

Number 1 bothered me as well. The justification I came up with was that the in the previous months they had been very careful with the youngest boy but as time went by without incident they began giving him a longer leash and clearly got lax. I guess the one thing to remember is that this family has already been living like this for almost 3 months at this point.

reply

#2 ... Well maybe the husband thought that opening up the condom package would be too noisy??

(just kidding)..

1) As for the pregnancy.. well, i was an EMT, and delivered a few kids.. It's not a quiet procedure at all - especially if you don't have full staff, and a surgery room. The noise of a child emerging from the uterus is quite loud.. A "slippery" noise of a human fetus separating from another human being. I don't know if the director knew this or not. He did have a child with Blunt, so i'm sure he must have dismissed this very critical detail.

2) If he was NOT in the operating room. Maybe he should have done his research.. There's plenty on YouTube..

3) I've been in the medical field for a long time. From EMT to higher levels. There was never a time, in my experience, let alone other physicians, where a woman didn't cry out in pain, or to grunt to push the kid out. Even if a woman has never been pregnant - they can tell you a least a bit what it's like when they have their monthly (cramps). And it's not something you can just "bear in silence" - if they don't have something to alleviate the pain..

4) She had great expressions? But even her moving around in the bathtub would have alerted the alien. Hell, if a walking raccoon on soft ground can get snatched.. then i'm sure a woman writhing around in a bathtub, can definitely get it's attention.

The beginning of the movie - i thought that was strange as hell, if the audience already knew the premise of the content, and the director has this kid zipping around the store, climbing up on shelves, and tipping stuff off accidentally. Well.. it's obvious he's trolling the suspense crap..

Also, when the deaf daughter, leaped down on her knees to catch the item, he tipped off the shelf? Sorry, she's no "banta" weight. Which means, if she pulled a "Gene Kelly" - dropped and slid on her knees to catch whatever he tipped over - that would have been the end of the movie right there..





reply

...the director has this kid zipping around the store, climbing up on shelves, and tipping stuff off accidentally.

I initially thought those scenes were used to establish the threshold of loudness that could occur without triggering the aliens. But the raccoon snatch scene ruined all plausibility there.

reply

1. He believed he was the best super dad in the world post apocalypse alien invasion. Instead of smacking the little shit or showing him bad gore stuff to scare him from doing crap like that or to any of his other children, he took the liberal route and just said this is a no no but the kid was like fuck dat shit just like how the sister ignored her dads orders to put that crap down and lets go.

2. Reasonable to get preggorz but the fact that he took her out with the kid when she could go into labor at ANY GIVEN TIME just shows what a horrible husband, dad, parent he is.

3. Nail was magical and only meant for her. Aliens need not apply. Again, this movie forces itself into stupid scenarios to give the tension it needed to give you the loudest shrieking deaf defying sounds to your ears you deserve to drive some plot, if any, forward.

https://youtu.be/azFsk42kb5E?t=1m39s

reply


2. Reasonable to get preggorz but the fact that he took her out with the kid when she could go into labor at ANY GIVEN TIME just shows what a horrible husband, dad, parent he is.


There is a shot of a calendar that shows the due date was several days away - maybe even two weeks. The baby was early. It happens.

reply