MovieChat Forums > Atypical (2017) Discussion > People complaining about the lead actor ...

People complaining about the lead actor not being autistic


I don't know much about autism, so forgive my ignorance, but wouldn't someone with autism have a hard time dealing with some things that come with acting and all of that? Would it really be realistic to cast someone with autism in such a show?

reply

People (certain people) complain about everything.

reply

Yeah, people are idiots.

reply

Complaining about that is kind of silly... the biggest issue with him isn't whether he really has autism or not, it is that he looks a lot older than 18. To me that is the biggest miscast of the whole show, they used a lot of actors that are 7 or 8 years older than they are supposed to be and it shows, sometimes it can be covered a bit but if the show goes for several seasons it will only start looking more and more miscast as the actors age shows more and more vs the age of the character they are playing.

reply

He's also not a high school student. That's why they call it acting, it's pretending to be someone else.

reply

No shit.... but if you have a part for a 10 year old you don't get a 30 year old... likewise this was a part for an 18 year old so someone closer to 28 is kind of stupid, especially when they look like a mid-twenties person. The way they look has nothing to do with whether they can act. Meryl Streep can act but she would be a bad fit for a movie where she was supposed to play a 18 year old coed simply because she looks much older and nothing you do is going to change that fact.

reply

Acting is a learned skill, 99.999999% of all 18 year olds suck at it, the rest are mediocre. Keir Gilchrist is killing it, and he's 25, not 28.

reply

Not much of a reader are you. I said "...someone closer to 28..." DIdn't say he was 28 only that he was closer to 28 than to 18 and at 25, guess what he is closer to 28 than to 18. Also I never said he couldn't act only that he was miscast because he looked like he is mid twenties which according to you he is.

reply

Nice try, but I know what you meant.

reply

Oh... a internet psychic.... How many finger am I holding up... Nope you missed.

But hey you win the prize for dumbest douche bag.

Next time try simply reading what is written instead of trying to read what you want to see, maybe then the cops won't be knocking on your door because you knew the girl really meant yes when she say no. Moron.

reply

You seem very upset. Next time just look up the person's age, it takes two seconds.

reply

Technically they could, like how they cast someone with cerebral palsy to play the role of Walt Jr. in Breaking Bad. Just a less severe form.

reply