MovieChat Forums > Van Helsing (2016) Discussion > Three years and no apparent explanation ...

Three years and no apparent explanation of how food/water lasted?


Aside from the "sharing showers to conserve water" reference, did I miss the part where they explained how the 3 people inside the hospital survived for 3 years in respect to food/water? With the collapse of civilization, public water would only last so long, same for gas/electric.

Yes we have Axel the Marine, infected Doc and the mystery girl on the bed surviving for 3 years and don't mention what their sustenance was (aside from Axel's blood for the Doc)?

FEMA recommends a food supply of 2 weeks for a full patient contingent, this would be 78 times that. I suppose that could be reasonable, but the shelf-life of some things (especially the freezers and fridges requiring power) would be significantly hampered.

https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/f&web.pdf

reply

They said in the first episode I think that they were going out and scavenging from stores in that area. They talked about it. Beyond that its movie magic. I really don't care though. I like it anyway.

reply

The show is OK, but that was just a question. But if Axel does not permit anyone to leave, how do they do the scavenging?

reply

the mention in second ep they go on scavenging missions nearby

reply

If Axel does not permit anyone to leave, how do they do the scavenging?

reply

Axel doesn't trust them going in and out. He doesn't know the majority of people now in his "bunker", he went out and got canned food, supplies. He also mentions catching rain on the roof I believe although maybe the city water still works since the vamp population would need to keep humans alive to feed on.

reply

With the exception of the windmill for electricity (which got damaged) there are a whole lot of assumptions and guesses going on.

reply

Episode 1.01 shows Axle in the kitchen area counting canned provisions and supplies when John walks in demanding to be able to go out looking for his wife.

It was mentioned in 1.02 that there are a ton of other places around they haven't searched yet. The challenge is getting to the more outset sites.

reply

Food a water bedamed who is cutting their hair, washing the clothes and cleaning up Doc's poop ????? ;)

A man can never have too much red wine, too many books, or too much ammunition
R Kipling

reply

Do vampires poop?

reply

They don't since their only food source is blood.

reply

No, vampires don't poop and Vanessa didn't eat for 3 years since she was considered dead. They got their food and water in the same place Axel got his cigarettes! When it's supposedly been a national goal to wipe out smoking for years now, why does Hollyweird still have to show characters smoking (a lot!) in some of the stupidest circumstances. Here, they are up against creatures with enhanced senses and this dedicated & devoted Marine shows no concern that they can smell him coming before they ever see him . . .

I do still watch some American TV series, but rarely movies since finding how good Indian movies are which are much more family friendly. They also have characters puffing away, but they start the movies with some really graphic warnings about the dangers of smoking cigarettes and drinking alcohol. Then any time during the movie when characters participate in either, they put warnings on screen. I still don't understand why directors don't just eliminate those things in movies instead of having the warnings on screen, but at least their laws are more consistent. You can eliminate a lot of things from a movie and no one is going to worry about it. You can create an epic generational tale and never once show anyone eating a meal, but we don't doubt that the characters still do eat meals. Why not eliminate the smoking and drinking and those who have a need to think of them doing such things can go right ahead and make them smokers and drinkers while the rest of us don't need to give it a second thought. Same thing with all the in-your-face sexual situations. When I see a couple kissing and gazing into each others' eyes, I'd be willing to bet real money (and I'm a penny pincher) on what they are going to do as they stroll off into another room. For those who want to see in-your-face sex, there is more opportunity than ever before to watch porn (much easier than it ever was for my generation to view it), for those of us who would like to give them their privacy, why can't we just stick to being mature enough to know what's going on without having to have it in our faces? Perhaps that's what I really dislike about Hollyweird is how they have no confidence in the intelligence nor the imaginations of viewers; obviously, they believe that everyone is so stupid that they have show them every detail . . .

As someone else said, it's movie magic and that's what I tell myself when these insignificant gripes come into my mind. All in all, I'm enjoying the series so far - no need to get too serious about reality, right?

Shauna & Ms. Phoebe, my God-given Happy Pill

reply

Yeah I don't think vampires have a bm, lol. I did see a movie once where they pee blood though. But she would have to wait 8 weeks between feedings because he was giving her whole blood. I don't think 1 person could keep her going long at 1 pint every 2 months.

reply

Actually I was wondering that myself. The Doc was turned back, and took a prolonged HOT shower three YEARS after the whole world went to hell! Where did the water come from, and how the hell did they manage to still have hot water in the pipes, and how the hell did they still have fuel to run the generator!? Lazy writing.


Did any of you guys see "World After People"? That showed us how fast the infrastructure would collapse without any humans to maintain the systems: No water, No food, No electricity, No heat, basically nothing would work after a very short time, and then there's all the big disasters: The nuclear plants going into meltdown, because the lack of cooling water, leaking highly poisonous radiation out in the atmosphere, and the chemical factories blows up and leak millions of gallons of toxic fumes out in the same atmosphere, the oil refineries blows up, creating gigantic out-of-control fires, that will consume enormous areas of land, in a very short time.

It would be a apocalyptic period of biblical proportions, and I doubt anyone would survive for long, not even Vampires.

___________________________________
But that's just my opinion. 💀

reply

Lazy watchers is more like it. They had a windmill that provided power. In the second episode it s destroyed so they had to turn on the generators. They grow plants. The vampires keep the power plants going to help keep the sunlight out (they haven't said how that works yet). The vampires keep food farms where they keep humans as blood bags.

I am sure more questions will be answered by the 13th episode. I swear everyone has ADD and can't watch an episode all of the way though, then they come on here and complain. 😖







Fate is what you call it when you don't know the name of the person screwing you over.

reply

Hum. I think it more have to do with the quality of the show. Been forcing myself through episode after episode but can honestly say that the writers are so bad that I prob won't make it all the way.

Seriously. The memory of the characters is between 5-10 min, after that they say things and bahave in ways totally against all they said or did before, like they've never said or done it at all...

The food/water feels like such a small thing to think about when everything else is so awful...

I don't really believe the questions will be answered in ep 13. Probably they come up with an answer that have nothing to do with anything that's happened during the 12 ep before. Bad memory, bad script, that's perhaps what is consistent in the show...

reply

Bravo Trekboy_nx! My first thought was "lazy imaginations," but your answer is more inclusive.

Shauna & Ms. Phoebe, my God-given Happy Pill

reply

The Doc was turned back, and took a prolonged HOT shower three YEARS after the whole world went to hell! Where did the water come from, and how the hell did they manage to still have hot water in the pipes, and how the hell did they still have fuel to run the generator!? Lazy writing.


More like poor critical thinking skills and ignorance on utilities by the viewer. Tons of places within a city actually run on wells. If city water goes out, people can still have access to water via wells/pumps. Assuming the pump is hooked up to a generator or solar power. Water goes into a water heater, it's stored there until someone turns the hot water on. "Having water in the pipes" has nothing to do with it. Even if you're in the city, you can still rig up a system that allows you to have a reservoir, pumps hooked up to generator can then pump water into the water heater and out the shower head. There's plenty of ways to get running, hot water if city water goes out.

"World After People"? That showed us how fast the infrastructure would collapse without any humans to maintain the systems: No water, No food, No electricity, No heat, basically nothing would work after a very short time, and then there's all the big disasters


Wells/pumps. People living out in the country do not get city water. They rely on wells. Simply rigging up a country home with solar will allow you to have hot water and lights. It's one of the handful of reasons the first thing to do in a widespread disaster is to gtfo the city.

reply

Apparently Marlboro and Winston are still running strong though.

reply

When there is sunlight outside, they can go to Costco and grab all the supply.

reply