MovieChat Forums > I, Daniel Blake (2017) Discussion > Is this film suitable for a 11 years old...

Is this film suitable for a 11 years old girl?


I love Ken Loach and I've seen almost all his movies.
From the Italian (I'm Italian, yes) trailer, "I, Daniel Blake" seems almost a "family movie" - something like "Raining Stones", for example. So, I'm thinking to take my 11 years old daughter to see it.
Do you think this film is suitable for a 11 years old girl?

reply

It's a 15, so I doubt she'll get in. Plus, films that are 15 now would have been 18 when I was a kid, so I'd suggest probably not.

reply

I think that it's only the strong language which pushes it from a 12A to a 15 rating. I have no children myself, but hypothetically, I wouldn't object to my 11 year old child seeing it

reply

She saw it with me and she liked it!
It's a good movie, she said, but very sad.
Yes, the language is strong, but in the Italian television (or in our streets) a kid usually hears words of that kind.

reply

My children are in their 20s these days, but I would have no hesitation in taking them to see this film. Why? Cos its a good portrayal of how inhuman government organisations relentlessly ground the vulnerable down into the ground. These are important life lessons, and your daughter has properly described the response that the reality of this movie conveys about the impact of government policies against the poor

reply

there are certain cirmumstancies when a film should be adapted for a younger audience, the language pushes this to a cert 15. this is a prime candidate for slight censorship. many 11 year olds would understand the messages, it should be seen by a wider society.

reply

I agree.

reply

[deleted]

As there was in The Exorcist (?).

reply

If you don't mind your daughter hearing curse words and if she already knows what prostitution means (it's only 1 scene), there's no problem.

Se non ti disturba che tua figlia ascolti parolaccie e se lei giá sa cosa significa la prostituzione (solo é una scena), non c'é problema.

reply

not suitable for an 11 year old girl, or anybody else in italy, because the film is dubbed.

reply

Most know English

reply

there's one slurred use of the c-word *beep* and a subplot involving prostitution, but it might be good for discussion. i'd say it's suitable for 12+ years, it's a very important film

reply

I agree.

reply