Tahani...

I think it's clear by now that all four of the principal resident characters don't belong in the "good place." Tahani, in life, was big into charity in an effort to please her parents, and to one-up her famous sister, as you said. (She's also snarky, and a name-dropper.) Chidi spent his life writing a book which was never published, and never really did anything directly to benefit the human race. The other two have confessed to each other that they don't belong there (though Jason is so dumb it's hard to believe he'd be smart enough to pull off the fake monk persona from the start of his afterlife).

My guess is that it's not the "good place," but some kind of purgatory.

You can't expect perfection from a person!
I'm sure Tahani and Chidi never sank a ship or tricked people into becoming a designated driver. They just weren't *beep* people and were "nice".

Worst housemate story:
https://worsthousematestory.wordpress.com/lina-carrero/

But it's also that whole idea if you're giving to charity does it really matter the reason behind it? Not really at the end of the day you are doing something good. One could argue all charitable actions have selfish reasons behind them.

> I honestly don't think she's that much of a good person!

Well, she was listed in second-to-last place on the list of good people. She barely made the cut.

But, consider that we've met two people that don't belong in the good place. Maybe there are more.

One thing that I want to know more about is how Fake Janu got there. We know from this last episode that two Eleanors with the same name died at the same place at the same time. That seems like a one-in-a-trillion piece of bad luck. It would be just too amazing for two Janus to have died at the same time and place. And, if Tahani is a fake also, that's three. There has to be another way that not-so-good people are slipping into the Good Place.

--
What Would Jesus Do For A Klondike Bar (WWJDFAKB)?

I can see Chidi getting into Heaven. Yes, he wrote a boring book, but he was also a teacher. The way people act in Heaven, at least initially, reflects how they were in real life. Chidi's reaction to Eleanor's confession is to help her. He's a nice guy. He didn't just happen to arrive in Heaven like that after a lifetime of being useless. He must have been helping people all his life, just in local, personal, small ways.

Tahani is a lot more problematical (and so are many of the peripheral characters in the Good Place, who share a lot of her characteristics as shallow people with First World problems). For a start, she was rich and spoiled in life, and Jesus is famous for saying that it would be easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to get into Heaven.

That's because she's prideful. She is also spiteful, judgmental, hypocritical, a hideous gossip, two-faced, and kinda mean. She has some depth (we know she was, if anything, the best of her horrible family), and we've seen her softer side at times, but a paragon of virtue who deserves paradise? Not even close.

The Historical Meow http://thesnowleopard.net

I really like Tahani. She's such a wonderful friend to everyone, and she never expects anything in return. She genuinely seems to care. In the flashbacks, I got the impression she did all those things because she wanted to, but was never good enough for her family (and it may have driven her, but she still did them). I don't believe there's ever a selfless good deed anyway. We're all human. It seems like, now that she's already in the good place, she just likes to help people.

She comes across as a bit condescending at times, but considering it's literally her only flaw, I'd say she's earned a place there.

While The Good Place does only accept the most elite of humanity, it's given the audience the idea that only perfection is allowed. No one's perfect. We're not robots. No matter how good a person is, there are still flaws. He did go over the algorithm, so compared to the rest of humanity, she's in the top percentile allowed there.

It seems like the criteria for judgment in this universe have more to do with the external results of one's actions than purity of heart. I also wouldn't judge her motivations quite as harshly as some, though she's no saint.

She seems to genuinely like people and want to be helpful. If anything, she's stuck in an immature mentality since so much of what's going on with her stems from her painful, rejecting, competitive relationship with her family.

I don't know, I agree she is conceited and a bit of a snob, but I don't think her motivations were outright selfish.

Its not that she wants to one up her sister, its she wants to get out of the shadow of someone whose been better than her since they were children.

Really Tahani is a textbook case of a superiority inferiority complex, she acts all smug and constantly brings up her own successes, but really she's just treading water. Underneath it all she's very insecure.

Now she did good deeds to make herself feel better, but really its good debate whether it counts as overall good if your not doing it so much to stroke your own ego, but to stop yourself breaking down.

Besides she did apparently just barely scrape into the Good Place.