MovieChat Forums > Fifty Shades Darker (2017) Discussion > Serious Question about homeliness

Serious Question about homeliness


I have a sincere question and I'm not trying to be rude, just trying to understand...why is it in these novels made into movies that the unrealistic story line of an interesting and incredibly attractive man "falls" for a woman on the plain/boring side? We saw this scenario play out in Twilight, and I'm wondering if it's because the writers of these books are trying to live vicariously through this unrealistic fantasy, because they were/are on the boring and plain side? It seems like they are attempting to transcend themselves into these female characters. Anyone else agree? Disagree? Why?

reply

My personal opinion is for a book to achieve any kind of success, the writer absolutely needs to live that character. They're breathing their life literally into a mere thought that was once rolling around in their heads. It's pivotal to become her/him and, if it's a romance, they need to fall in love with the hero of the book. When this happens, that's what creates that magic that people talk about. El was Ana. Nicholas Sparks was Noah. Jane Austen was Elizabeth Bennet.

Like actors who say they become their characters while shooting, a writer lives in this world they've created until the last draft is completed. It's absolutely surreal at times--actually, most times.

No, all the time.

~Keep some room in your heart for the unimaginable~

reply

Hi TheFilmLuvR, the writer of Fifty Shades, was a happily married television producer wed to a successful television writer. She loved the Twilight novels and used them as a template for her fan fiction. Stephenie Meyer, the author of Twilight, concocted of fantasy of a girl who meets an anti-hero with a dark secret. Jane Austin used it in Pride and Prejudice, Bronte used it in Jane Eyre. E.L. James added sex and BDSM to weave her tale and created the Fifty Shades novels on her blackberry as she took the train back and forth to work. I agree that the writer has to immerse him or herself in the story, but that in no way means that anything in their life is lacking. Authors write what they feel.

reply

I don't consider Dakota homely...so maybe it is just a preference...and as far as Christian..he has had all the beautiful women he ever wanted...with Ana, he felt something he had never felt with any of the others...and so the fantasy continues.

reply

Hi isundling, I think you meant to reply to the original poster. I have never said that Dakota is homely or that the fictional character, Ana, was homely either. I also didn't mention the world homely in my post. Ana is supposed to be average, not homely.

reply

Isundling, and her wrong place posts, and Diva's frustration with it <----I'm going to miss this BIG TIME .

~Keep some room in your heart for the unimaginable~

reply

I will too, Ms. Stacy.

reply