MovieChat Forums > The Girl on the Train (2016) Discussion > Megan miscast

Megan miscast

posted 8 years ago by chillpillory
29 replies | jump to latest

In the novel, Megan is described as being almost irresistibly hot. I don't think bennett is hot. I think she's not thin enough and not pretty enough to be irresistible. She's good looking (not my type), but the Megan character needs to be almost supernaturally beautiful. Whenever I see Jessica Biel in a movie, she's almost too gorgeous to watch. I can't follow the movie. Megan needed to be like that.

In the movie (IMO), bennett is the LEAST attractive of the three main women (Blunt, Ferguson, Bennett), and it's not like she has an enchanting personality or dazzling brain. In the book, she's described as being stunningly gorgeous.

[–] brandon_8321 8 years ago

Really? Lok

[–] chillpillory 8 years ago

I don't think bennett is attractive, but that's just my opinion.

[–] gab_guardado 8 years ago

Don't agree

[–] rosewater86 8 years ago

I think she's prettier than Emily blunt and Jessica Biel. Haley is cute in an ethereal fairy-like way and it's that youthful look that better portrays the character's vulnerability and naivety. The only blondes I can think of that would fit your description of Megan is Amber Heard, MacKenzie Mauzy, Dianna Agron and Margot Robbie.

[–] bobby_nynex 8 years ago

ur joking? shes one of the most beautiful women i have ever seen. amazing actress as well.

https://youtu.be/93sGUFpVxFI

[–] 8 years ago

[deleted]

[–] chillpillory 8 years ago

not joking. I don't like her body or her chin. But I don't think Jennifer Lawrence is attractive, and to me, they look a bit alike.

I think Evangeline Lilly when she was on LOST was the prettiest girl in the history of creation, but not everybody agrees with me.

[–] her_majesty_lola 8 years ago

Are you serious? Her acting was subpar at best.

[–] 8 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 8 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Killy-69 8 years ago

Lo what.

[–] Dan_Garten 8 years ago

Everyone is miscast in this.

[–] VerucaPepper 8 years ago

I have not seen her in anything else, but I think she did an amazing job with this role. And she is very different looking, especially her eyes, but very pretty.

[–] xix_azn_luv_xix 8 years ago

She was eh.