Ruined by Hallucination and Annoying Flashbacks - Season 3
Not so much Season 1 and 2, because hallucinations and flashbacks tended to flow well with the story, but Season 3--where half the time you couldn't tell if something was a hallucination or a flashback, it got old very fast.
Episode 9 is plagued by being purely hallucination and John's perspective the entire episode. Instead of moving the story forward, writers thought it would be a good idea to do an entire episode--the one before the finale, to take place almost entirely in John's head. What a wasted opportunity and it takes down my review of the season immensely.
Season 1 - 10/10
Season 2 - 9/10
Season 3 - 4/10
The pacing is annoying right from the start (Kevin goes back to the crime scene what, 3 times in 3 hours? So stupid), the music not as good, the tension, and most of the atmosphere, is missing from Season 3 which is what made Season 1 & 2 so good.
The "five months later" we got only just a few episodes into Season 3 really threw everything off balance, though slightly remedied by some intriguing court scenes. Meg being out of the show for half the season was really weird. Are we really supposed to believe that Belle and Kevin would keep their cellphones on, pinging cellular towers in Cuba?
We're told by Diana that "Janey's having sex" yet we've seen no evidence of that happening, or her relationship with her parents at all throughout the season. She's hardly in the season, only a handful of appearances, and most of them are within John's hallucinations. Then there's Ben, the boy, who got maybe 3 scenes in the entire series...
Ozzy's storyline... WHERE were they going with this? What an absurdly annoying character and horrible storyline. I wanted John to run into this guy face to face and him punch him down, but it never happened...
O'Bannon's storyline... suddenly dropped and he falls off the map, then in the finale we find out he's still in jail doing community service for the next 30 years. Yawn. Why didn't we get to see him speak in court? WHY didn't we get to see him lay out what happened from his perspective in the courtroom? WHY did he not fight for his innocence better? WHY did he not get a proper conclusion, being a main character from the very first episode of the show onward?
Then the finale features the liberal global warming/climate change establishment injection of "Rayburn House will be underwater within 10 years" made me laugh out loud, the windows weren't open but I bet the neighbours heard. Sigh. Very unfortunate.