MovieChat Forums > The Hateful Eight (2015) Discussion > Very small detail that bothers me

Very small detail that bothers me


First, I am a big fan of the film.

I am not normally one to nitpick small details but there is a "what are they thinking" moment in this one that makes me shake my head every time I watch it.

While in the stable OB and Mannix decide to run a line from Minnie's to the barn and another to the outhouse. As they show them running the line to the outhouse they both have an armload of stakes, drop them in a pile near the road and start running the stakes. Now, they each grab one stake, walk out towards the outhouse and pound them in the ground at which point they return to the original pile, grab one stake, walk it out...

All signs point to them repeating this process over the entire line which adds a ridiculous amount of time and three times the distance to the job. For perspective, with each guy laying a stake every ten paces, assuming each "pace" being roughly three feet which has both guys laying six stakes and guesstimating the distance to the outhouse was that of a football field from goalpost to goalpost, we get:

Option A: Carry all of your stakes with you, the entire job covers roughly 240 yards (120 out, 120 back).

Option B: Leave your pile at the "goalpost" and return to the pile after setting each stake.

Stake 1 (goalline): 10 yards out, 10 yards back, 20 yards total.
Stake 2 (own 20): 30 out, 30 back, 60 total.
Stake 3 (own 40): 50, 50, 100.
Stake 4 (opponents 40): 70, 70, 140.
Stake 5 (opponents 20): 90, 90, 180.
Stake 6 (opponents goalline): 110, 110, 220.
Option B has each guy covering roughly 720 yards.

It's freezing with high winds and blinding snow, I can't see them making that job so much more difficult than it had to be.

reply

Yep

reply

[deleted]

Those metal stakes are heavy. Who wants to lug them around every ten yards?

My guess is they nail in about 3, then haul the rest up. Then nail 3 more and and so on. They're not going to go all the way back to the beginning each time. But they're not going to haul the entire load if they don't have to every ten yards.

Seize the moment, 'cause tomorrow you might be dead.

reply

Actually, anyone who has worked with metal in the freezing cold, sub-ten-degree weather knows you are exactly right. I did that once -- once -- and quickly learned that trying to handle all of the metal at one time, in the blistering cold, was ridiculous. At first I was like: "Oh, this is nothing. I can do this, easy. I'm not even really cold at all". About two minutes later I could barely bend my fingers. I thought my hands were going to freeze to the metal pipes I was handling. And that was only 12 degrees outside, not a blizzard!

-----

Shooting has started on my latest movie: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5531336/

reply

I got the idea that they were doing it the "funniest" way possible, kind of like how they hammered the board into the door every time.

It might not have been realistic but it was funny.

Never hate your enemies. It affects your judgment. -Michael Corleone

reply