So many reasons this movie sucked...
First.... as always, Hollywood just loves to portray anything Catholic in a negative light, i.e. evil nuns, shabby orphanage, starving the children, desecrating a statue. Sigh. Getting a little old. This beginning to the movie already put me in a negative state, not a smart move. I guess Hollyweird hasn't figured out that Catholics are watching this movie and paying for movie tickets!!! Dummies.
Second: The actor playing Hook just sucked. His mannerisms, his facial expression, the way he talked, guy just about everything about him was just bad.
Third: The costumes of the Indians....OMGosh can we say GAUDY!!
Fourth: The Indian princess should have been a real Indian!!!! Hollywood = Dumb
Fifth: The fairies should have been kicking butt in the very beginning, why did they need Peter to motivate them? What did Tinkerbell say to Peter? Why keep the audience in the dark.
Sixth: Something about Blackbeard just over the top, he wasn't a cool villain.
I think Isaacs did a much superior job.
These are just on the top of my head, I'm sure I will think of more.
God loves you as if you were the only person on this earth.