MovieChat Forums > Concussion (2015) Discussion > Calvin Johnson and Marshawn Lynch retire...

Calvin Johnson and Marshawn Lynch retire at 29


I wonder if there'll be even more star players retiring early like this when their talents are still in demand then guys who stuck around too long only retiring when the NFL teams no longer need them. Like play about 8 seasons make your money and get out while you still have your mental capacities.

reply

Position players like running backs and WRs have always retired earlier than QBs Offensive lineman, and Special Teams. Nothing new there.

reply

Running backs don't make it much past 30 but a lot of Wide Receivers make it to 35 before the dropoff.

reply

a lot of Wide Receivers make it to 35 before the dropoff.

You pulled that out of your butt. Just being on an NFL team as a 35 year old is practically unheard of at any position (aside from QB). Even the absolute best WRs have trouble finding a team when they reach their 30s. Take a look at Wes Welker (who still wants to play) and perhaps my favorite WR, Chad Johnson, who couldn't find work at age 32 and had to go to Canada. The burly Andre Johnson, who was just released by the Colts after a rough season, is 34 and unlikely to find a team to give him another chance. Same goes for Roddy White and Mike Wallace (only 29!). The list goes on, but can you even name ONE WR who is producing at age 35? Fortunately for them, they make so much money that they can retire with no worries if the were even semi-smart with their finances.

Calvin Johnson is a special case because he was arguably the biggest and strongest WR to ever play in the NFL, so it seemed like he would be able to play for a long time and still be productive given his size and strength (kind of like Shaq). His retirement at this stage just tells me that he doesn't love the game as much as other WRs, like Terrell Owens who would still play now if somebody wanted him, and he didn't want to stick around with his speed and footwork beginning to wane. Most guys want to keep playing at his age for 1) money, 2) love of the game, and/or 3) desire to win a Super Bowl. Evidently Calvin realizes the Lions are nowhere close to winning a Super Bowl.

reply

I can see more young Athletes starting to lean toward baseball and basketball,, GAURANTEED money and way less health risk....baseball will probably see the biggest increase in talent,, hopefully black parents start getting their kids into baseball rather then football,, baseball has been missing talented black athletes in the past decade, hopefully guys like Granderson, Adam Jones Andrew Mccutchen and Starling Marte' are paving the way for the young black athlete to get more involved in a better paying, less violent sport! Antwan Randel El is on record saying if he could do it over again no doubt he would if played baseball instead

reply

I can see more young Athletes starting to lean toward baseball and basketball,, GAURANTEED money and way less health risk....baseball will probably see the biggest increase in talent,, hopefully black parents start getting their kids into baseball rather then football,, baseball has been missing talented black athletes in the past decade, hopefully guys like Granderson, Adam Jones Andrew Mccutchen and Starling Marte' are paving the way for the young black athlete to get more involved in a better paying, less violent sport! Antwan Randel El is on record saying if he could do it over again no doubt he would if played baseball instead


True. Many NFL players were complaining last year when NBA players were getting huge contracts.

http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/25231384/in-wake-of-nba-spending-spree-redskins-safety-says-nfl-players-are-underpaid

reply

This is all about the Outliers argument. To play at the highest level you need unbelievable talent and the chance to play the game again and again from a young age. Let's look at the four major sports and their demographics:

Football: Mostly poor black players with a few corn-fed midwest white players and white QB's and kickers. This is because black kids can play for free in high school, and middle school in many cases, and then they are given scholarships to keep playing. Many positions are very speed and strength oriented where they pick up what they need from an X's and O's standpoint in high school and college. QB's are a complex, technical position where they've been groomed since elementary school with private coaches, travel team leagues, and are often the sons of NFL QB's themselves.

Baseball: Historically a white sport because of the barrier to entry to play caused by the need for expensive baseball fields, equipment, and paid umpires. The timing, coordination, and skill requirement makes it tough to pick up in you teens, and you need to start from the time you're at least in elementary school. However, in the past 20 years, we've seen tons of Latin talent due to it being the major sport in the Island countries, and while they are poor, they have tons of space to baseball fields.

Basketball: Typically seen as a mostly black sport due to the lack of equipment needed to play, and abundance of basketball courts in the inner city. Young kids would play basketball every day of their youth, and the best would win scholarships to prep school. The tide is shifting as the game is becoming more and more international, and as recruitment starts younger and younger. Kids from wealthy families (often times still black, but wealthy families) take the process seriously and hone the skills from a young age, the way that young QB's do.

Hockey: Pretty similar to baseball but with a higher barrier to entry. Most schools don't even have hockey programs. Ice time and equipment is incredibly expensive and has the highest barrier to entry. Ergo, all white dudes with a few token rich black guys from wealthy family.



Remember, the abundance of a race in sports does mean that a race is doing well, like it does if they're involved in the sciences or politics or business. Its a way to escape tough situations if you have the rare talent for it. People forget that decades ago, Jews were disadvantages and dominated basketball.

reply

It's very rare a Running Back is in the NFL past 30.

Receivers usually last pretty long as they don't get hit as much. Calvin being so big probably took vicious hits as that is the only way to get him down, which could be the reason he retired so young.

reply