MovieChat Forums > They're Watching (2016) Discussion > Greg's keffiyeh (his black and white sca...

Greg's keffiyeh (his black and white scarf)


As someone who BARELY knows the significance to that type of scarf in the Palestinians vs Israelis and their story and everything (being purposely very careful with my wording), would Greg, a soldier in Afghanistan, be wearing that? And why do they never mention it.

From the little I know, it is hugely significant. Did they tread carelessly there or am I just an idiot?

I have read is that a black and white scarf would indicate Palestinian solidarity.... or something... I am so out of my league with this question.

Can anyone comment about that part?

I really liked the movie, by the way. I loved it, actually.

reply

I can't answer your question, but I did want to point out that he wasn't a soldier in Afghanistan, he was there filming, same as he was doing in Moldova...I can't remember fully what it was but something like a documentary of a girl's boarding school, to help show how the country was progressing or something?? I kept getting thrown off by that too, when the girl woke him up & he freaked out I thought "wouldn't a soldier with PTSD be more likely to snap into survivor mode & attack her straight off the bat?" or I'd think "good thing he's there so they have someone who knows how to defend a position" & things like that, but the actuality was that he was a civilian, not a soldier...& they made the mistake of filming the funeral in Moldova & pissing everyone off, so maybe he unintentionally did the same kinda thing while in Afghanistan with the scarf...

reply

The keffiyeh is a symbol of Palestinian solidarity, however it has unfortunately also become a fashion trend among young people who are completely ignorant to it's significance. Urban Outfitters actually labels them as "Anti-War Woven Scarfs" and offers them in a variety of colors.

reply

lol they arent even in style anymore. They were like 7-10 years ago. Its funny what white hipsters will do.

I read this in a chola accent.

reply

I served 20 years ago and I still wearing mine. Mind you, it's not black and white. It's OD green. But I am in no way a "hipster"

reply