Why it didn't feel real


So when I first watched this I was struck by how the concept seemed good, but when watching it still felt incredibly unnatural and even, at time, slightly nauseating. There's this really weird thing that the brain does when interpreting vision. It's called saccadic masking. You can google it, but the long and the short of it is that the brain edits out blurred things from rapid eye movement. Look at something then look to the side at something else. Did you see all of the blur? Probably not. You brain hid that from you. (It's a rabbit hole of weirdness that includes explanations for things like looking at a clock and at first it seeming like the second hand or digits froze for too long.)

So my point is that, if you want to truly do a first person POV for a film like this, you need to do what the brain does. You need to edit out bits and make eye movement jump instead of be a continuous movement. I would imagine that could be done as a mix of software and human editing, but I would love for someone to tinker with this and see if they can create a more natural feeling first person visual narrative.

reply

I OPENED THIS THREAD PREPARED TO ARGUE, AS I LIKE THE FLICK...BUT THEN YOU SPOKE ONLY RATIONAL TOTALLY CORRECT WORDS...I SEE WHAT YOURE SAYING AND I AGREE.


reply


Same here - never occurred to me how big a problem it could be until unsanesarah pointed it out

I guess it's a similar issue with angled camera views. In real life, leaning your head 45° should turn the world 45° the other way, but the brain corrects for the rotation. It's weird.

reply

I agree. It probably is not possible (yet) with a camera to fully simulate a person's view.

reply

Interesting point. But I'm wondering if our brain would struggle with a preprocessed images? It might see it the same way strobe lighting in a film just jumps about?

reply

Depends on the brain

reply

Given our actual perception, this movie actually works better on a (semi-decent sized) TV screen, as opposed to cinema....to which it gave me (and several others in original attendance) motion-sickness
'CLOVERFIELD' was a similar movie that had a likewise effect, resulting in my local cinema issuing warnings for such.

reply