MovieChat Forums > Alone in Berlin (2017) Discussion > The Book

The Book

posted 10 years ago by valis1984
15 replies | jump to latest

Alone in Berlin (1947) by Hans Fallada is superb. Read it before you see the film.

"Everyone is ignorant, only on different subjects". Will Rogers (1879-1935)

[–] 10 years ago

[deleted]

[–] mrs_bean 9 years ago

How? It's based on the book written by a German national after the war.

[–] dmnkeen 9 years ago

Hans Fallada was a German who died shortly after this book's publication at the end of the war. The book is a fascinating insight into life under the Nazi regime during WW2, and was written in circumstances that could have lead to the author's execution if the manuscript was discovered.

In what way is this pro-Zionist?

[–] ThomasMuf 9 years ago

bear022013-588-696101, another anonymous piece of fascist dog poop. Crawl under your stone and die.

[–] CameronPoe80 8 years ago

ThomasMuf,

People like you are the reason European towns are being completely ethnically cleansed and European women are afraid to go out on New Years Eve. Total scum. Die, marxist filth.

I'll laugh when people like you are attacked and mutilated by the savages you brought in, scum.

[–] janney_ms 10 years ago

i really love the Quangel's/Trudy story and i forgot her name but the lady who ''adopt'' the child at the end (mrs ennis something like that) story but i was bored with the others...i skip some pages because of that. i'll Watch the movie for sure because of Emma Thompson! i hope they focused on the Quangel.

[–] Gary-P-D 9 years ago

Couldn't agree more. Fantastic book which I've read several times. Unfortunately I can't see the film doing it justice,even with the impressive cast. But,has there ever been a film that does outshine the book?

[–] philliplawler 8 years ago

Agreed too. A smashing book. The atmosphere created is thick with fear, paranoia and helplessness. It really does bring the period to life as best as possible. The film I'm sure will be good given the quality cast but the atmosphere of fear will be difficult to concoct to the same level. I'm still looking forward to it.

[–] Gary-P-D 8 years ago

Yes, I too am certainly looking forward to the film. But, I'm afraid I'll be a harsh critic! It's a niche genre that has always interested me and the book catches it magnificently, which will be almost impossible to create on screen. We can only hope......and I'll try not to be to harsh!

[–] 8 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 8 years ago

[deleted]

[–] elisabettaduo 8 years ago

Do you feel like it's a prerequisite to have a better grasp of the movie or are you just saying it was an amazing book?

I am asking because I will be watching the movie (despite the rating) so that I can make up my own mind about it.

thanks

[–] valis1984 8 years ago

If the film is well made there will be no need to read the book for "a better grasp of the movie" but it was "an amazing book" and I feel its impact would be diluted by seeing the film first.

"It is a good thing for an uneducated man to read books of quotations" Winston Churchill (1874-1965)

[–] elisabettaduo 8 years ago

True but I made clear I haven't watched the film so obviously I couldn't know if it was well made. Thanks for the tip about the book anyway.

[–] hoov-4 8 years ago

I agree valis I've read a few of his books and always felt like I was living his words. Excited to see this picture!