Latina refugees cry so hard that mother nature gives them a town built out of nothing, without labor or sacrifice or hard work put in by ancestors. A situation where male labor that would've been necessary to construct the entire foundation of their civilization is just magically manifest with zero effort, where the primarily female families can live with the town magically providing them with whatever they want, whenever they want it.
Sounds like a modern leftist interpretation of the world and a mirror into their innermost thoughts about how civilizations arise and the lack of value they have for the sacrifice and hard work of our forefathers.
Why? Probably being too gung-ho about the ethic of progressivism and treating it like a virtue, at the expense of even basic acknowledgement of the immense struggle and sacrifice necessary to build our civilization. That type of respect is a generally conservative ethic, and focusing on the future is a generally liberal ethic. If you go too far in the conservative direction you get ossification and an inability to adapt to a changing world, and too far in the opposite direction and you destroy the foundation of your civilization because you simply take it for granted.
Encanto is yet another modern Hollywood movie that shows how widespread that type of hyper-progressive, hyper-leftist thinking is.
There are other examples of it in the movie too. Like repetitions of the strong female trope, the myth of the successful matriarchal society, and yet another tired retread of the trope of the bumbling useless man. (The first male who speaks at any length literally has clownish features for no plot reason and is oblivious to them, and a female has to heal him as he humorously and cluelessly tries to give life advice to his daughter, obviously undercut by the fact that his face is grotesquely injured from his own mistakes.)
I hear that the grandmother is a real bitch, does that mean that it's trying to show that all older women are bitches? What is the myth of the successful matriarchal society?
But the Madrigals and the others do work to keep the town running.
Yes, they got a new spot to build a town on through a miracle.
That is not the same thing though as that they get everything for free afterwards.
And again, let me point out an important thing that you clearly missed about this story:
They got a miracle only through the sacrifice of a man.
So I don't see how you can complain about "strong females" or "matriarchal societies" here.
That is not what is going on in this story.
Agustin was more than just your typical bumbling dad though.
He always did what he could to help Mirabel and even tried to stand up to his mother-in-law at one point.
And sure, you can feel that Julieta was almost too perfect.
But I'm glad that at least one member of the family wasn't suffering and had emotional issues.
And I must give Julieta credit for being the only one to try to comfort Mirabel after she first saw the cracks.
I think you might have hit the nail on the head as to how delusional the leftists can be about how the world works. The ones in Hollyweird, the ones pushing for socialism (mostly because they can't hold down a job and suck at succeeding in life), and the ones on welfare, really don't understand just how much hard work goes into not only making their daily lives comfortable, but also how difficult it truly was to build a civilization.
I mean, all that stuff they enjoy, someone worked hard for them to be able to get it easily:
Food - someone had to farm it, sell it to supermarkets, someone had to ship it to the stores, and stock the shelves.
Water - someone has to run the waterworks plants that extract it from rivers and lakes, make it clean and safe to drink, pump it to the different neighborhoods, take the waste water to the sewage plant, filter out all the crap, and send the leftover water back to the waterworks for cleaning for use again.
Electricity - someone has to take care of the power plants that produce said electricity, someone has to build the wires and power lines that go to different parts of town and go into all the buildings
Internet - someone has to take care of the servers and monitor the programs being used online, and protect against viruses that would destroy regular people's computers, as well as update the apps running everything
Most products in stores - someone has to make or harvest the materials required for them, someone has to work at the refineries, someone has to assemble these items in factories, package them, and ship them to the stores, someone has to drive the trucks, pilot the freighters on water, or fly airplanes to transport these things, and someone has to stock the shelves
To completely dismiss such things and write them off as magic just goes to show how stupid some people can be. There's a reason they used to teach us about this stuff in school when I was a kid. Now teachers focus solely on woke shit and forget what our kids really need when it comes to operating in the adult world. We're now seeing the end product of that.
Then they wonder why people in rural areas, who get up early and work hard daily to produce the raw materials required for all this stuff, have differing political views than someone in a city who sleeps in, has no job and spends most of their time at their local coffee shop trying to out 'highhorse' strangers on the internet.
You're not saying anything that anybody dosen't already know. Why do you right-wingers always feel the need to shove your right-wing viewpoints where nobody asked for them? This is just a Disney kids' movie, and you and the OP are just reading into it a lot of s*** that isn't there in the first place. It's not a political movie, but yet you're trying to politicize it anyway. Get a life, please----everything is not about you or your tired-ass right wing views. Do that on the board of a political movie, not here. It's always you right-wingers goin around the internet and IRL trying to shove your right-wing views down everybody's throat. I don't see left-wingers doing that as much as you crazy fckg right-wing nuts do. Every damn thing in life isn't about being right-wing or left-wing---the fact that this is the only way you see life--through such a narrow-minded lens is really sad and pathetic. Your crazy whackjob cult leader with the transplanted hair lost---get the hell over it, please.
No, I am not. With you right-wingers, you whole damn lives revolve around kissing the orange idiot's fake dried-up sagging two-faced a**, in hopes that he'll give you a little pat or scratch on your fckg heads. How pathetic as hell you are.
Yep! You can always count on a leftie eventually exposing themselves away as the nutjobs they are. Their Trump derangement always exposes itself, complete with obscenities. It's incredible. Leftists don't force their views on anyone? Really? Everything they talk about is politically based, and they're always happy to make others adopt their whacked out views. Just look at our schools; they're starting on our kids now. They have to be taught about how racist America is, they have to be taught about homosexuals and sex, they have to be taught how America (and only America) is polluting the planet and causing global warming. They're basically taught to hate America.
I'm on disability pension and can't believe what I'm reading here.
Don't you think that I know that other people work just because I can't work?
That is very prejudiced.
And no matter what you think about Hollywood, they know that people have to work as well.
Besides, the people in this movie do work.
It is never stated exactly how many people live in the Encanto.
But except for the Madrigals, they are just normal people with normal lives.
And the Madrigals must work as well.
It is the most clear with Julieta, who is the local healer, and Luisa, who has to do all the heavy lifting in the town.
But they all have to do something for the community or face Abuela's wrath.
While the magic will make some things much easier for them, it is not like they get anything for free.
So please, stop seeing a message that isn't there in a fantasy movie!
Actually, what's the message of the END of the film?
Elite family that dominates the community suffers from the downsides of power - stress and self-esteem and the pain of too much responsibility. Film ends with the family still ensconced in the elite and dominating the community, but they've stopped stressing themselves and worrying about responsibility! Why, it's a stealth right-wing message!
Seriously, this is a stupid movie, the nonsensical story meant that some very nifty animation was totally wasted.
I didn't think the movie had any sort of message to be honest. It was just a demonstration of different events, it didn't try to impart a lesson to the viewers.
I guess so. It was a weak story overall, but my kid didn't mind. For a kid's movie it's as deep as any of the Despicable Me movies. Which is not up to the old Disney's or Pixar's standard.
It doesn't have real strong moments usually found Disney's movies.
It also has little adventures, also unlike other Disney's.
Finally, the timing between the whole house came into ruins (the only relatively strong moment) to the subsequent happy ending was too fast and too convenient. Deus ex machina style.
It doesn't have strong moments usually found Disney's movies.
Well, we have to agree to disagree on that one.
It also has little adventures, also unlike other Disney's.
That is not quite true, I think.
I have to say that Mirabel going into Bruno's tower and then into the secret passage way was two adventures.
Finally, the timing between the whole house came into ruins (the only relatively strong moment) to the subsequent happy ending was too fast and too convenient. Deus ex machina style.
Well, they had to build a new house without any magic powers before they got that happy ending.
So it would have taken some time in-universe and wouldn't have been a Deus ex machina within the story. reply share
Well, that was my opinion. It technically has all of it, it just felt weak. Do you think this movie's story is as strong as what in comparison? The Lion King? Monster Inc.? Inside Out? Frozen? Coco?
Remember all those scary stories Trump and the right wing media tried to sell about the immigrant caravans? Of course Republicans would hate this movie.
But in the first year of Biden multiple immigrant caravans have come across the border and been allowed into the country without so much as a COVID test....
Really, I don't believe that you understood the movie at all.
Let's start with that there was a sacrifice made so that the miracle could happen.
And it was a man, who had to be murdered to save the lives of his family and his neighbors.
Sure, it is true that his widow, a woman, became the leader of the new town.
But it was only thanks to her husband's sacrifice, that she could get this position.
It is pretty clear that if Pedro had still been alive, he would have been the leader instead of Alma.
So I don't get how that can be interpreted as a leftist fantasy.
It is not true either that the Madrigals don't have to work to get what they want or need.
Rather, it is made clear that Alma put too much pressure on her children and grandchildren.
And speaking of which, she is hardly portrayed as perfect.
It is actually most likely that she would have been a better mother and grandmother if Pedro had lived.
Again, saying that no men are important in this story is just not true.