MovieChat Forums > A Most Violent Year (2015) Discussion > New York: The Quietest City in the World

New York: The Quietest City in the World


Regardless of how you felt about this movie--if you were mistaken and thought it was decent, or correct and thought it was bad and pretentious and airless and stupid--a curious thing that can't be disputed is how New York CITY has zero ambient noise as depicted in this movie. No sirens, no car horns, no passing buses, no birds singing, no wind rustling, no children playing. Much like the real New York City, much like the real anywhere, the entire planet earth retreats into utter silence so you are free to make your perfectly worded speeches that sound like you're reading them off a cue card because no actual people speak this way without fear of so much as the bell on the bars of a kid's bike interrupting your Michael Corleone impression. I've taken quieter hikes in Vermont. This "choice" by the "filmmaker," much like Albert Brooks' dimestore toupee, set the bar for realism in this absurdly overhyped piece of film school garbage. (I don't care for the movie, btw)

reply

You're right. This movie does sound extremely antiseptic to be 1981 NYC. It wouldn't have been that hard for the filmmakers to have captured some ambient city noise and added it to the final mix in post. I also would've like to have heard some period music in the background: Billy Joel, Blondie, etc. Maybe that wasn't in the budget?

"Visions are worth fighting for. Why spend your life making someone else's dreams?"

reply