MovieChat Forums > A Most Violent Year (2015) Discussion > How bad was New York during the 80's

How bad was New York during the 80's


As a youngster, the 80's signifies transformers, the Cold War, Reagan's Star Wars program, and the movie Wall Street. How bad was New York City during the 1980s? I understand that the crack epidemic made the situation worse but the way that period is described today, you would think it was close to hell on earth, where rape, murder, and corruption was part of daily life.

reply

In late October 1980, I passed through Manhattan to drop off a friend who lived there, after which I would go on to VT to spend a marijuana-fueled week in Killington. It was a Sunday, about 7am, and looked to be a nice day, with little traffic and very few people about. To think about the horrors of what had happened there in the naked city the night before were too twisted, violent and depressing to want to try and comprehend. I dropped off my friend and told him it was nice to have known him. I then continued on into the forest of the dying leaves of that autumn and the dark prophecy they told of one of the city's more famous residents, a once great voice of peace and popcorn, soon to be silenced.

I love the colors & cool weather of fall; pumpkins, Halloween, s**t like that.

reply

Exactly what "twisted, violent and depressing" horrors had happened the night before your arrival?

reply

One can only imagine. It's the city, and someone violently died that night. Maybe sometwo, somethree, or more. God only knows how many small animals were tortured and young children molested. It's night in the city.

I love the colors & cool weather of fall; pumpkins, Halloween, s**t like that.

reply

I grew up in the South Bronx and yes I grew up in the projects. Luckily for me I joined the US Navy and thrived in the service and also attained my degree.

What do you want to know?

Crack Cocaine demolished our neighborhood, sure we were poor but we were also happy. Once Crack infiltrated the neighborhood it was a huge downfall. My best friend growing up also saw the worst of it, his mom was on crack cocaine. One night I went to go see my buddy and he wasn't home, his mom asked I will suck your d(^k for 20.00 dollars. I couldn't believe it and I never told him that story. Later on that year she was found dead.

Gangs were everywhere, if you weren't from my neighborhood you were going to either get robbed or pummeled.

COPS, no one ever called them because they were in on the take. COPS only came hours later to remove the dead bodies!

I was shot at numerous times just for standing outside and also chased out of several locations. It was ridiculous!

I never go back there as most of my friends are either locked up , killed, or doing the same crap they have been doing for 20 years.

Anything else you wanna know?

http://theboricuacritic.blogspot.com/

reply

I remember visiting Manhattan in 82 or so when I was about 14. A friend of my dad, who was born in the Bronx but grew up in Yonkers, was a record producer, and we visited him at his office, which was right near Times Square. Times Square was full of XXX theaters at the time. I remember walking by a drugged-out dude who threw his paper in front of my dad and then started screaming at my dad for knocking the newspaper out of his hands. "Keep walking" was what my dad said, and eventually we left the guy behind. But there were lots of other drunks and druggies and sketchy looking people. And this was in the middle of the day, mind you!

The friend's office building was old and run down. When we got inside the office, he shut the heavy reinforced metal door behind us, and there were --no lie--about 10 locks down the side of the door.

I went back in 1987 after my freshman year of college, staying with my friend's sister in Connecticut. We rode into the city every day, and never had any negative encounters. SoHo hadn't been gentrified and was full of art galleries. We went to the theater district and Times Square, which was very different from when I was there 5 years earlier!

Ed Koch was the mayor during the early to mid 80s transformation. David Dinkins followed, then Giuliani, then Bloomberg.

reply

Lived there in 82-83, and yeah, it was a pretty bad place. I lived in the lower, lower East side, 2nd & B. People dealing heroin/crack on most every single corner. Muggings were very commonplace. And at the time, it was truly a 'look the other way' city. Someone could be stabbed in broad daylight, and no one would lift a finger.

Violence. If it's not solving all your problems, you're simply not using enough.
-Zaraki Kenpachi

reply

What's kind of weird is that I went there by myself in 1982 for a trip. I stayed somewhere in Midtown, I think. I went to plays, went to bookstores, and walked the streets during the day. The only violence I remember of that time was in 1980, when my mom took my brother and myself to New York. When going back to our hotel by cab one night, we saw two cab drivers get into a fight. That was about it from what I saw. But, the city didn't strike me as particularly violent. But, I guess I just got lucky!

I. Drink. Your. Milkshake! [slurp!] I DRINK IT UP! - Daniel Plainview - There Will Be Blood

reply

Been reading the comments from those "who heard things and were there" and alot sounds exaggerated. Sure NYC had its bad times but so did other cities.

I think people are taking the title and synopsis of the movie to the extreme.

reply

yep, some of the posts seem written by fledgling screenwriters. But think of this too; you got a thousand people living within a couple of blocks together like NYC(thinking high rises, here) chances are your probably goint to witness some of the crime. Now where I live in rural Mississipp, you can take 1000 people, still have the exact crime rate(there's big med addiction down here) and yet never really ever see any crime or anything out of the ordinairy, simply because people live miles away from each other.

reply

You had to live thorough those years to understand the contrast of what it was like compared to today. Most people I talk to about the Bronx in the 70's don't believe me. It is true that things started to turn around in the mid 80's, but just google for images of the Bronx in the 70's to see what I mean. It looked like a war zone.

reply

Time for some for you to break out Midnight Cowboy and Taxi Driver.

reply

For all the posters doubting just how scary NYC was at the time, there are tons of Google images, movies from that time, and archived news stories at your disposal. I was 11 in 1981 and I can attest to the fact that the city was indeed a very dark, scary, intimidating place throughout the '80s. The subways were terrifying graffiti-laden hellholes, prostitutes and pimps all over Times Square (not to mention all the XXX neon-lit porn shops lining 42nd St.), very dark residential streets, garbage and litter everywhere, and gang violence in the outer boroughs.

All that being said, I'm guilty of romanticizing the "old" NYC as it had much more personality (albeit scary), and had some kind of hard-to-describe edge that just doesn't exist anymore. The club scene was much wilder, more "free" and unique and the city had vastly more club choices then. There weren't all these big box national chain stores and suburban-style restaurants that one could find in Anytown USA and the rents were cheaper (even adjusting for inflation and by today's standards).

I'm glad for the lower crime, for sure.


reply

Born and raised in Manhattan in the early 70s (and have remained since).

We were on Central Park West, but two avenues over (Amsterdam) was completely off limits to my brother and me: there was a murder/month in a flophouse down the street on Columbus. Now, that flophouse is a luxury condo, and the entire neighborhood is chichi boutiques in that stretch (Columbus in the 70s and 80s).

My older brother and I were routinely mugged (not violently) by other kids from the area who in the summer would take our skateboards, and in the winter, our sleds. Once or twice we chased after them and got our stuff back. It was sort of ridiculous -- benign but scary nonetheless. Far more scary: the subway. And Central Park. However, I did live a fairly sheltered life, to the point that it was possible for me (apart from the silly muggings) to grow up on the Upper West Side with little awareness that a world of crime was bubbling in my midst. I do enjoy the cleaner, safer city nowadays, but must say I miss Times Square of old. Yes, it was mostly porno shops/theaters, street walkers, drug dens, seedy joints, but it was also incredible theater. Now it's Disney and theme restaurant/store hell, with equally bland theater. At least it had character.

reply

The question of how good or bad things were in New York City in the period around 1981 very much depends on what part you are talking about. Generally the mayhem and crime noted in the statistics at the time were occurring in the outer boroughs and northern Manhattan, and the lower east side. Midtown, Wall Street, the Upper East Side, most of lower Manhattan, was relatively safe, as were outer areas like most of Staten Island, Riverdale, Douglaston, Forest Hills etc...

Just like much else of urban Amarica at the time, crack cocaine was a huge problem causing a spike in crimes. AIDS was also a very new thing, but the effect was more cultural if you will than on crime per se.

Since then crime of course has gone down to a fraction of what it was across the city. But it's imo not been all good. You had a great and very active music scene at the time. It's more diffuse and imo not as eclectic now, less innovative.

Much of the squalor has also been replaced by an antiseptic retail world. Imo safer does not have to mean less interesting, but in NYC today it has meant that.

reply