MovieChat Forums > Ugly (2014) Discussion > Shoumik is the real hero of the story

Shoumik is the real hero of the story


I saw this movie a few days back and it’s one of the best Indian movies I’ve seen. Although there are no likable characters, I feel that somehow the character of Shoumik deserved to be called a hero (of shorts).

The only positive thing about the whole story is that the police found 8 disappeared girls (while trying to find Kali). This was achieved by the relentless efforts of Shoumik Bose. He pulled as many strings as possible. Made deals with thugs etc. He also covered many possibilities (hidden by father, kidnaping for ransom, sex trade etc.).

Why did he fail? –
1. Chaitanya led the investigation astray when he made the ransom call.
2. It was proven that he made the call and he admitted. Because of this, his credibility as a witness was zero. Chaitanya was the only witness to point at the masks salesman as a potential suspect. So Bose had to disregard that line of investigation.
3. Then the girl’s father, his friend and even his girlfriend totally screwed up the investigation by the ransom game.

Some comments here says that he was playing a game with Rahul but I don’t think this was the case. He felt guilty of the way he treated the girl (memories of him tearing up her photos with father while he was in a car) and wanted to find her. If he was playing a game, he would never have asked Rahul’s help with Chaitanya (He was too proud for something like this).

Anyway, he did not give up till the very end. But both the biological parents ran away.

Mother – Not interested in finding the girl. Became a thief and stole from her own father. When she discovered her friend has betrayed her, she shot the ONLY PERSON who had the capacity to find Kali (if she’s alive) in anger. Then ran away.

Father – Never let go of the faith he had on his so-called friend (who had an affair with his wife), did not co-operate with police, insisted that Bose had Kali, became a thief and finally a murderer. Ran away.

In the end, Bose was the only person who was with Kali’s body. His efforts were futile but he was there.

reply

No one actually is the "hero".. Shoumik was a sadistic hyper masculine misogynist arrogant cop. He let his hatred for Rahul, his wife and Chaitanya bias his investigation. He just wanted to pin Rahul down somehow because he was bullied in the past. A case of bullied becoming a bully.
If anything, it was the IT girl who was actually efficient and prompt throughout the movie and even traced the investigation back to the mask seller.

reply

[deleted]

And don't forget the IT girl saying, "We could've saved the kid, Sir!"

I want George Clooney for the President

reply

Hi, this is an entirely different topic but im asking here where theres activity, hoping you can inform me of something please.Is this a bollywood film in the sense that it has a song and dance every twenty or thirty minutes throughout?
Also, are there (m)any indian films that dont have the singing and dancing..?
I have a chance to watch this one tonight but i must find out first!
Thanks,

GeaF

reply

This is not a typical Bollywood movie the westerners usually have an impression of. And yes, there are many Indian movies without song and dance routine.

Go ahead and watch it.

I want George Clooney for the President

reply

Hey thanks a lot for bothering to reply!
You have me interested now. I love films from around the world as I am Scottish and get tired of the same old UK or USA movies. Indian film is one I have avoided up til now, due to my terrible opinion of Bollywood movies(because of the singing and dancing!).
Let my foray into Indian films begin here!
If you wish to recommend any that you like, please do.
Thanks :)

GeaF

reply

Well, I watched the movie with my wife and we both enjoyed it! I especially liked the incompetent police officers having jokes when the men were trying to explain about the missing child! Hilarious.
Unfortunately we both felt that towards the end the movie became a bit farcical. A bit like a 'caper' film, the old British Michael caine type farce. That isn't to say it was not enjoyable. Very well produced also. I want to watch more.
:)

GeaF

reply

[deleted]