Wouldn't Aquaman have won easily?
Maybe I'm forgetting something. Despite Aquaman being the butt of many jokes, he controls most of the planet because most of the world's surface is water. You'd think he'd have countless legions of armies and sea life able to wipe out one lone island of Amazons.
Still my favorite JUSTICE LEAGUE film, though.
http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/