MovieChat Forums > The Affair (2014) Discussion > Whitney is the worst. (spoilers)

Whitney is the worst. (spoilers)


I get it, teenagers are terrible. Why does every show feel the need to drive home the fact that teenagers are the worst people to ever walk the earth. Sure, some are bad but my sister is 17 years old, beautiful, popular and does not even come close to this kind of behavior. The characterize Whitney in the most unreasonable, unoriginal archetype of a teenager to ever exist. What does that say about the writers who have nothing better to do with their teenage characters other than make them the most atrociously unlikable young adults to ever exist? And I swear to god, the majority of shows always end up having the teenager daughter character be promiscuous with older men and they end up pregnant (or losing their virginity to them or something else equally uninsurpied). I really like this show but can't stand any of the younger characters and feel slightly insulted that the writers can't come up with characters of a little more depth. The only thing Whitney brings to the show is her fling with Scotty which is completely inconsequential. Sure, it gives Noah a teeny bit more motive for killing Scotty but that alone is completely unrealistic. All I'm saying is that if Whitney's only reason to exist is to be a pain-in-the-ass teenager, she has no reason to exist at all. Give the viewer a little more credit.

reply

Since the focus isn't on Whitney, there's not time to show her as a well rounded character so that you don't see her good points -- how adorable a baby and child she was, how bright she was, how loving until she hit that teenage thing.... Whitney represents some of the turmoil and difficulty her parents -- who are the story's focus -- have to deal with. Noah loves his kids and his wife, but we're shown why he finds that life unfulfilling and full of uncertainties and bumps in the road.

reply

Yep I find her awful too. But given the circumstances you kinda can't blab her

reply

Yes she's awful! What a s h i t t y attitude but I love her anyway! She's so gorgeous and plays the part really well. I can't wait for S3!

reply