MovieChat Forums > The Affair (2014) Discussion > more evidence Noah and Juliette are the ...

more evidence Noah and Juliette are the same person


Noah says he "knows a guy who knows a guy" when talking about that special book he gave Juliette. When talking about that special book she was reading, Juliet says she was able to get a hold of that book, cause she "has her ways."

Noah was reading a book about himself - something about Peter Pan I believe.

You see the destruction that she-beast laid? I'm being risk-averse, considering.

reply

How do you explain all of the scenes where people are interacting with Juliette?

--
Why don't you take a pill, bake a cake, go read the encyclopaedia.

reply

This!

reply

Exactly, Juliette never had any interactions with any of the other 3 core characters, except perhaps Alison seeing Noah driving Juliette's red car, which I think belonged to Noah anyways.

You see the destruction that she-beast laid? I'm being risk-averse, considering.

reply

But she met Whitney. Is Sabine (the daughter, I think that is her name) fake too?

reply

It's been speculated on this board, that the entire finale in Paris was quite bizarre. It wouldn't be too far of a stretch to assume it was all talking place in Noah's head.

It was only Noah and Whitney in Paris, even more evidence Noah and Juliette are the same person, because Juliette only had a single daughter Sabine - who was actually Whitney.

You see the destruction that she-beast laid? I'm being risk-averse, considering.

reply

You seem to have forgotten to take your pills.

reply

[deleted]

Except there were all of those scenes with her class in America, her family, her friends and fellow professors in France, Whitney...

She had no reason to meet with Allison, Helen or Cole as it wasn't required of her storyline.

--
Why don't you take a pill, bake a cake, go read the encyclopaedia.

reply

It's odd Juliette would have nothing to do with the other core characters. Her part was small, but significant enough, she should have at least met one of them. All those scenes in America can only fit into the overall storyline if she's in Noah's head, like Gunther was.

Gunther smokes French cigarettes btw

You see the destruction that she-beast laid? I'm being risk-averse, considering.

reply