MovieChat Forums > Whiplash (2014) Discussion > A very well made bad movie

A very well made bad movie


Great direction, great dialog, and a fabulous sense of pacing, but the characters are awful. This jazz teacher would’ve been fired decades ago. Makes no sense. But i think the movie is so well made that people ignore how cartoonish Jk Simmon’s character is, and how douchey and unlikable Miles Teller is.

reply

Sounds like Clarke Kent here is suffering from superhero complex. Not every character is made to appease you.

reply

Wrong. Conservatoires only recently started getting a proper look-in from educational standards boards. Abusive teachers from older generations (and sometimes from other countries where drill-sergeant teaching is the norm) have lurked in these places for decades.

Simmons did a great portrayal of one, and he was matched by Teller’s superb rendition of what it’s like to be on the receiving end.

reply