MovieChat Forums > Me and Earl and the Dying Girl (2015) Discussion > What she realized during the movie at th...

What she realized during the movie at the end...


It finally occurred to her that he loved her...and then in her room after she died, it finally occurred to him that she loved him...I guess.

reply

I think it is not about love, but more about recognition. She, at the very last moment before slipping into coma, never keeps her eyes out of the film Greg made. Why? It's because "no one has done more to make me smile, and no one ever could". He also realizes she is not a burden, but the best thing that has come across his life. All of this in a dialogue-free, breathtaking musical moment.

reply

I agree with you, but all this doesn't mean there was no love. You wrote yourself : Greg realizes that Rachel is "the best thing that has come across his life". Feeling this, how couldn't he love her ?

In any case, "breathtaking" is a good choice of word. I almost find that scene TOO brilliant for an otherwise nice but never mind-blowing drama.

___________
- Booker, are you afraid of God ?
- No. But I'm afraid of you.

reply

[deleted]

Don't read the comment section of a film you haven't seen. Have some self control.

reply

haha! indeed

reply

The title of the film pretty explicitly tells you her outcome. The film wasn't about that. It was about their relationship. I think the title kind of suggests exactly that.

Knowing she dies has no effect on the impact of watching it. It's not at all like The Fault in Our Stars where the whole plot is basically a competition the entire time wondering which of them is going to die.

reply

In response to OP, I interpreted it as to show to Rachel the faces of the people who loved and cared about her. He didn't put all of the depressing, sentimental well wishes that all of the students said during recording. He didn't put in any of her mom's reminiscing, but instead simply a close up shot of her face. I thought it was also poignant that the only person in his film who wasn't just profiled but actually showed grief was himself, as if to show her how much she actually meant him.

Why she basically died watching his movie I dont understand anymore than to see it as an artistic choice. As someone who teetered back and forth between hating it and loving it, that scene got me. It was beautiful. After some of the more on the nose parts, the subtlety and beauty of their completely nonverbal communication and conveyed emotion was something rare today.

reply

[deleted]

She kept asking to see it for a reason. She simply wanted to see it before she died. And since the movie pulls no punches she died while watching it but to her I think she just really wanted him to make it to get out of his rut.

reply

The love was there for both of them long before that scene. For me, it began the first time she fell asleep on him while watching movies.
Everyone they were with already knew it. Earl, Denise, Madison.

He just didn't know how much she really appreciated his selflessness until he saw the artwork, and the squirrels, and the letters. She always saw his acts, but he never noticed hers. Obviously she had been working on some of those things a very long time.

reply

So what did she realize then

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

So sad.


Lose the Game!!!!!!!

reply