It's painful to watch Kelley in a leadership position
Just from watching the latest episodes, it's clear that he has little ability to be a leader. He blew up at Sierra due to his own insecurities. In addition, he made several errors in front of Captain Lee. It's sad when the Captain feels like he has to babysit the boatswain.
I'm not a huge fan of Eddie, especially after his deeds last season, but he clearly was able to work with his crew better than Kelley. I would have liked to see Connie as boatswain this season since Captain Lee seemed very impressed by her.