Bob was HIM


I'd venture that not only was Bob not real, but Bob was HIM as a younger man. Not much is mentioned of Qohen's past/childhood..

Some clues:

1. When Qohen first meets Bob, we learn Bob can't be bothered to learn names because it's a waste of human memory. This is a clue for how Qohen became lost as a young man.

2. When Qohen is in the park with Bob, Bob asks Qohen if he ever had a girlfriend. Qohen replies that he did... when he was about the exact age of Bob. Hmmm.

3. Bob's mysterious sickness that seems to get worse at the same time Qohen is getting "better." Because his need for Bob as a mental construct is becoming less and less.

reply

how bout, no?

reply

It seems like a good theory but I can't say that I believe that. That would mean waltz knew everything but forgot it. How could a genius remember all those equations and formulas but never his own past.

I think qohen loved once which is stated but got hurt so bad that he decided to have no feelings or emotions. That's why he is so scared of the girl until she forces her presence on him.

reply

#1/#2: Qohen got married then divorced, he was definitely not "lost" at the age of 15. #3 Bob was sniffing chalk which he wiped up with the handkerchief and led to him getting sick.

reply

Contrary to the other posters, I think this is an interesting and viable inference. It's well worth pondering. The surrealism of the film makes it hard to come to any allegorical conclusion in a single viewing. One thought though; if Bob did represent Qohen, who was Management?


Reaction time is a factor in this, so please pay attention.

reply

I think you missed the point of Bob being today's youth. He's young and promising and can solve anything thrown at him...except how to live. He has no clue about the outside world. He sees two girls playing with a kite and could easily tell them how to fix it, but then complains he has never had a girlfriend. Don't you see the irony?

I think with movies like this (I just finished it eight hours ago), is that we are made to think so much, we start to overthink it. I know I do this all the time. Hell, I think the movie Frank is completely about Twitter, seen as a form of mental illness. So there's my crazy theory for you.

Not bashing or trolling you. I assure you, I could be wrong too, but Gilliam, for all his fancy sets and direction is actually pretty straightforward in his storytelling

reply

If this theory was true then the girl Would be a figure of his imagination too Because he introduced them in his home. I say nay

reply

Why would that mean the girl wasn't real?

reply

Well if you're saying Bob was a figure of his imagination (seeing himself when he was young) how can a real person shake hands with one's imagination? And your other argument, saying that he mentioned he had a girlfriend when he was his age; Bob Does not have a girlfriend so that's a difference between them. Maybe I misunderstood you...

reply