MovieChat Forums > Fifty Shades of Grey (2015) Discussion > So Ana can stand rough lubeless anal, bu...

So Ana can stand rough lubeless anal, but can't stand being whipped?

posted 9 years ago by ItsLukeyBitch
22 replies | jump to latest

Must be a plothole.

Rough lubeless anal clearly hurts more than some whips to the ass and yet Ana goes crazy on the end cause she didn't knew what she signed for, the guy was very clear what he wanted, he was clearly pertubated and yet she didn't think twice before jumping on his dick, she signed a contract thus allowing everything he could do to her, he whipped her on the ass 6 times, he roughly penetrated her many times with no lube aree we supposed to believe anal didn't hurt?

"No one is gonna take my soul away i'm living like Targaryen"

[–] april_l 9 years ago

I don't think there was any anal in the first book/movie. Now, I've only read/watched 50 Shades once but I don't remember that. I don't think that she ever did sign the contract (again I'm recalling from memory). They talked about it and they were ironing out the details but as far as actually signing it, I don't remember it happening.

[–] ItsLukeyBitch 9 years ago

It was, i believe in their second sex scene on the movie, he turns her around and starts penetrating her from behind, not sure about the book (haven't read it and likely won't read it on the future).

It wasn't actually onscreen, it was implied she accepted as she says she agrees and then their affair continues.

"No one is gonna take my soul away i'm living like Targaryen"

[–] april_l 9 years ago

But was it actually anal or just doggy-style? I really don't recall.

Then it was completely changed from the book because not once in three books did she ever sign it (that I recall).

Others know the story better than I do so someone else will probably clarify it, if I'm wrong.

[–] ItsLukeyBitch 9 years ago

It was anal, it's clear he's penetrating her anally and her reaction also confirms it, she seems in pain cause he was being too rough.

I have a friend that read the first book, she said Ana signed it on there, but just like the movie it's something strongly implied.

"No one is gonna take my soul away i'm living like Targaryen"

[–] april_l 9 years ago

Hmmm, I don't know but like I said I only watched it once at home.

I looked it up and Ana never did sign the contract in the book (isn't the Internet a wonderful invention, lol). It's odd what things I remember about the books and what I can't. I'll never get around to re-reading the book though to ever clarify though lol

[–] Amazona20 9 years ago

It was anal, it's clear he's penetrating her anally and her reaction also confirms it, she seems in pain cause he was being too rough.

Ummmm, Ana was a virgin, did you know? It was not anal but somebody else in the board thought the same so you're not alone but didn't you think it was strange when after rough anal sex without lube she smiles and says "that was really nice"  to wonder and find out what the heck am I missing here??? 

how do you know she was in pain? you don't see her face and the sex sounds in this movie are pretty tame.

She does not sign the contract but agrees to try, same as Christian agrees to try regular relationship stuff like going to a movie.

[–] isundling 9 years ago

It was doggy style...Christian puts on a condom...no lube..and Ana is enjoying it immensely...remember the comment in the office, when she asks Christian.."what are butt plugs"?...second book, she wraps some up for his birthday, along with some other rather tame items...and he tells her the different sizes are for easing into anal intercourse...and that it takes time for it to be comfortable...and she will get her own..there is no way Christian would do that to her so soon..they also did doggy style in the red room of pain the first time he took her in there..

[–] april_l 9 years ago

I knew you could clarify it lol. Somethings about the books and movie I remember, others not so much lol

[–] april_l 9 years ago

I knew you could clarify it lol. Somethings about the books and movie I remember, others not so much lol

[–] isundling 9 years ago

Well..that subject has been brought up before, so I remembered my reply from that time..and it's kind of difficult when you have to quote from Book 2 to answer a post from Book/movie 1..and we know that Christian was very easy on Ana as far as the introduction of his type of sex...anal would have just been rude.

[–] april_l 9 years ago

Hey, it's better than I can do.

[–] shoppermom26 9 years ago

Ana never sings the contract. Your friend is wrong

[–] 9 years ago

[deleted]

[–] akeshishian17969 9 years ago

She didn't sign the contract.

[–] Arvin-G-Borkar 9 years ago

If you have sex with an uncircumcised penis, you do not need lube.

Thought you should know...

Reminder: The O.C. resets to its first episode on POP network April 1 @ 2 p.m. EST

[–] spaceman88 8 years ago

If you have sex with an uncircumcised penis, you do not need lube.

Thought you should know...

That's the biggest nonsene I've read today!

[–] Arvin-G-Borkar 8 years ago

It is true. The gliding action of the you know what and the skin forms a layer of which penetration goes uninhibited. I would ask if you are cut or uncut, however, this topic does not warrant it.

THERE IS NOTHING TO FEAR. COLLEGE FOOTBALL IS HERE!!!

[–] starzshine22 8 years ago

Ah yes...you need lube. A man's penis add's zero lubrication ....no matter if he is cut or not. If you'r going for the bum...you need lube. Male or female, lube is needed...

[–] starzshine22 8 years ago

Anna and Christian have not had anal sex...in any of the book's.... No penis to her bum....never happened sorry.
A finger and a butt plug...no anal sex...

[–] Kellymariekitty (158) 6 years ago

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏 agreed

[–] actionmanrandell 8 years ago

WRONG a whip can generate hundreds upon hundreds of pounds of force if swung properly. which do you think would hurt more? getting hit in the ass by mike tysons most powerful punch of *beep* in the ass with little amounts of lube? if you say *beep* in the ass then you are a *beep*

[–] nolatecharges 8 years ago

if done right along with other fun things...a whipping can be very pleasurable