can any of the hobbit cultists
really discount or deny anything said in this video or his few others??
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TijkFnT8D-U
Not a Hobbit cultist, but I can point out that some of those 'missing' character-establishing scenes with the Dwarves are there in the films: Nori filching objects in Rivendell (and being exposed for it in Goblin Town); Gloin complaining about being bled dry by financing the expedition. But there are too few such scenes.
"Hell hath no fury like that of the uninvolved." - T. Isabella
its obviously not black and white. but the attempt to "flesh out" the dwarves is sooo poorly done, ill conceived and ahlf hearted it results in no real results.
as he says the one dwarve (i forget his name, the older one I believe) who should of confronted THorin, doesn't at all and instead we get another dwarf with no motivation or precedence of doing so..
have u watched all this guys videos? hes pretty spot on
as he says the one dwarve (i forget his name, the older one I believe) who should of confronted THorin, doesn't at all and instead we get another dwarf with no motivation or precedence of doing so..I've only (recently, at least) watched this one video. And you're right that the movies do a poor job of establishing many of the relationships between the Dwarves. Balin and Dwalin should both be Thorin's most trusted friends and allies; he grew up around both of them, with Balin becoming older than Thorin in the films while Dwalin is a few years younger than the Dwarf-prince. We do see both Balin and Dwalin in the flashbacks; Dwalin mostly at the Battle of Moria.
"Hell hath no fury like that of the uninvolved." - T. Isabella share
its obviously not black and white. but the attempt to "flesh out" the dwarves is sooo poorly done, ill conceived and ahlf hearted it results in no real results.
as he says the one dwarve (i forget his name, the older one I believe) who should of confronted THorin, doesn't at all and instead we get another dwarf with no motivation or precedence of doing so..
have u watched all this guys videos? hes pretty spot on analysis
I liked The Hobbit film series. Surprisingly, I liked then better than the book and with that being said, I don't mind anybody saying anything against the film trilogy. I do have some nostalgia regarding seeing PJ's Hobbit trilogy when they each first came out.
Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Black Sabbath, and My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fan
What book did you read?!
share