MovieChat Forums > The Mindy Project (2012) Discussion > Do you actually WANT Mindy to get back t...

Do you actually WANT Mindy to get back together with Danny


I'm torn. As a viewer of the show, I really can't see where it would be going without Mindy being with Danny. The sexual tension between them was what kept the show going the first seasons, and them getting together has given them great opportunities for humor and tension since then. Also, I really can't see the show being about Mindy Lahiri, single mom. Not unless they went the Murphy Brown route, made Morgan the nanny, and didn't really deal with the baby that much. I just can't imagine this working.

BUT as someone who has worked with battered women in my lifetime, I feel like if I knew someone like Mindy, I'd tell her to run. I feel like Danny has always been sort of controlling (The episode last year where he policed her diet, I found disturbing, for example, or trying to trick her into having the birth he wanted), but I feel like the baby has just driven him over the edge.

I feel like it actually sets a bad example for young women to say that this relationship is okay and something we should root for.

I guess what I really want is for him to change, really change. Like, not have a conversation with Annette which makes him briefly realize he was wrong but actually have some real time with a therapist. I don't know if I'll get that though.

"Arguing with trolls is like playing chess with a pigeon . . . ."

reply

That's so interesting, I have also worked with women(and men) who have gone through domestic violence. During this season I have sat on the sidelines while people here and on Reddit have referred to Danny as an abuser; it has been really complicated to watch. Honestly, I'm not 100% sure that I would refer to Danny as an abuser. He's so close to the border that it's scary. There are lots of control issues and emotional barbs being thrown out there, but one could also make the argument that Danny's way of showing love is similar to Annette. He tends to take over and push the agenda that he thinks is right. Look at what a difficult time Danny has had saying no to his mother. He feels that she says and does certain things out of love so he excuses her behavior. A lot of that is mirrored in Danny and Mindy's relationship. While it is unsettling to see that in a mother/son relationship, it is even more frightening in a romantic partnership.

I can't completely classify Danny as an abuser, but his behavior is disturbing and unacceptable. I want to go back and re-watch episodes with Christina. She was made out to be a succubus, but a lot of her behavior (cheating and manipulating) could have been a response to Danny's controlling behavior.

Anyway, to answer your question, I am torn as well. While I don't see Danny as an abuser, I do feel as though he and Mindy's relationship is very unhealthy. You are correct in saying that the first two seasons were held together(paraphrasing) by Danny and Mindy's sexual tension and relationship. From the beginning, Danny has been as much of a developed character as Mindy. I honestly feel that they are right for each other. Part of the reason I rooted for the two of them is because they kept each other honest. Mindy has come an incredibly long way since the first season and I love how much she has grown. She has proven time and again that she is better than her previous thought process that she needs a man to be happy. However, I feel as though her relationship with Danny has proven that he is not just a man that she settled for. They feel like a real couple with serious problems and I would like to see how they work through it....if they work it out at all.

Some of us prefer illusion to despair.-Nelson Muntz

reply

I don't think he is actually abusive or even on the verge of PHYSICAL abuse. I just think he shows lots of warning signs, the controlling behavior, rigid gender roles, and isolation. The episode where he watched her on the baby monitor to make sure she didn't go out really freaked me out. And then, when he sees her doing WORK with Jody, he has sort of flipped out about it. He also expects her to be perfect, and if she's not, she's evil. He just seems to flirt with the line of being an emotionally abusive man.

Most abusive men were themselves abused. We know little about Danny's relationship with his father except that Danny hates him but is trying to forgive him.

Interesting point about Christina. In the episode, Weiner Night, with the photo exhibit, Christina portrays Danny as the devil and says, "I'm a survivor, a survivor who came out of a very dark time with a man focused on extinguishing my light" (Just went back and watched that part on Hulu). At the time, we assumed she was overreacting/overstating things, particularly because she had voluntarily gone back to Danny after a long absence. But I suppose it's possible she felt that way for some legitimate reason. Like maybe he really was that controlling. Even his ex, Jillian said something to the effect of there being only one right way to do things, and it's the Danny Castellano way.

I'd like to see him get help, actual help, so they can be together.

This is an interesting route for them to go on a sit-com. I've seen them do a relationship breaking up and coming back together on a drama I watched, Parenthood, and it was very contentious because, in an effort to make it arguable who was at fault, they sort of made the characters unsympathetic so, as here, you sort of didn't know what to root for. It's harder to tackle something like that in a sit-com where 1) They only have 22 minutes per episode and 2) You expect it to be funny. But we'll see. It seems like they'll probably get back together. I hope, if they do, they have another season (Parenthood did not) so we'll get to see if that was actually a good idea. I also hope they don't rush things.

"Arguing with trolls is like playing chess with a pigeon . . . ."

reply

That is a good point about Christina. When you think about it, a lot of the problems with Danny have been evident from the very first episode, when he called Mindy fat, or the second one, where he tried to prevent her having a power position in the office. He was just so sexist and mean that it was weird. People are saying that it is character assassination, but in a way, many of these seeds have been planted from the beginning. It's just we weren't expecting them to be relevant. We were expecting more of a character arc where Danny changed over the course of the show. But, when you think of it, how many sit-com characters really ever change. That's part of the thing of a weekly sit-com -- that the characters stay the pretty much the same. The situation might change, like a character could get a new career or boyfriend or whatever, but the characters stay pretty similar.

Also, the planting of all these clues about Danny is sort of smarter than I was giving the show credit for being. If they've really done years of character work to show us how Danny is NOT right for Mindy (when we thought they were trying to do the opposite), that's pretty clever.

reply

Also, the planting of all these clues about Danny is sort of smarter than I was giving the show credit for being. If they've really done years of character work to show us how Danny is NOT right for Mindy (when we thought they were trying to do the opposite), that's pretty clever.


I hate it when people are pompous on IMDB--and here I go being pompous. I said verbatim what you've said here, on about twelve different threads. The show is GENIUS for having done this and makes Danny a kind of Keyser Soze ("The Usual Suspects"): "the greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was making the world think he didn't exist."

I sometimes sit back and wonder if even Mindy Kaling is aware of how genius this is.

For what it's worth, I think Danny is an abuser. It's impossible to define him as anything but. He is no longer sympathetic--and the genius (yes, genius ) thing about the way the seeds were sewn is how they mirror bad romances in real life. Everyone, at the end of THE bad romance of his/her life, looks back and asks, What was I thinking?

And then you start to remember the This, and the That. The Mindy Project has been (did I use the word) genius at the scary, truly scary, realization of what has to be called Evil.

No joke.

reply

Right - I want to see him grow as a character.

reply

I have to agree with this, this time.

reply