MovieChat Forums > Arrow (2012) Discussion > I love all the support for Laurel now lo...

I love all the support for Laurel now lol


I find it very funny how people suddenly like Laurel now and want her back lol. I was her biggest supporter in season's 1 and 2 and remember them bashing her as well as season three when she first became Canary. Now that she is dead they suddenly want her back and she's the best lol. I find that funny.

reply

What support for Laurel?

I am a hater and I am glad she was gone. I was so upset when she appeared but luckily she was just Black Siren. That is fine, as I like the actress.

I am happy there is a new BC in town

reply

What are you talking about. She's always been polarizing. There was always a big amount of hate and love for her. Worse when it became a shipper thing.

The Emperor has no clothes.

reply

they are talking about in the show and team arrow's reaction. I think, cause thats what I notice.

reply

I was talking about Team Arrow's reaction yes. But I was also talking about certain fans that want Laurel back after bashing her. There is another board that is supportive of Laurel and here it's not supportive.

reply

hi to you too poison ivy





Do you mind if I have a piece of your thigh? It would complement this fine '76 Shiraz

reply

You're working on a flawed premise, that all the people that want her back now are the same ones that wanted her gone in the earlier seasons. I'm sure there were people whose opinions about her changed, but I would guess that many of those that hated her back then still hate her, and many that miss the character now always liked her. Different groups of fans simply became more vocal at different times. Personally, I always liked the character, although I haven't been one of those calling for her return, I've just lost interest in the show overall and stopped watching last season before she even died. Her permanent return probably wouldn't be enough to bring me back.

reply

You're working on a flawed premise, that all the people that want her back now are the same ones that wanted her gone in the earlier seasons. I'm sure there were people whose opinions about her changed, but I would guess that many of those that hated her back then still hate her, and many that miss the character now always liked her. Different groups of fans simply became more vocal at different times. Personally, I always liked the character, although I haven't been one of those calling for her return, I've just lost interest in the show overall and stopped watching last season before she even died. Her permanent return probably wouldn't be enough to bring me back.

👍👍

THIS! Laurel fans may not have been as vocal or as instent on constantly promoting their fave as certain other fans, but they have always existed. Saying that Laurel was universally hated in the early seasons is like saying that Felicity became universally hated in seasons three and four, just because there was a backlash from certain parts of the fandom, or because she lost her former "fan favourite" luster. Also, there are lots of people who are indifferent, even to contested or divisive characters.

In general I would say that fandom opinion about Laurel changed quite a lot in seasons three and four when she finally started her BC journey, and when the Laurel/Oliver relationship was definitely laid to rest. Maybe that's why the backlash against her death/demotion became so big....some fans who disliked Laurel in the early seasons wanted to give her a chance, and was disappointed with her marginalization and disgraceful demise. I also think it's true that sometimes you're more loved when you're dead than when you're alive!

reply

I don't claim that I only watched the show for Ms Cassidy's sake. The whole team of Oliver, Laurel, Quentin, Tommy, bad guys, snake mother, stepdad who was so nice I suspected he was a secret bad guy, and Merlin made it good for me.

But I couldn't believe all the hate she got from people who flopped facedown onto the floor at Felicity's feet and worshiped her phony, forced double entendres and called her every darling name in the book. I liked the character for her intelligence and upbeat personality.

Meanwhile, the lawyer who worked for breadcrumbs at the free legal clinic in the slums, risking her life and her happiness for the good of her impoverished fellow man, had to be the target of all that hate. I can't really get into it, it was so disgusting, especially the phony bullsht ("impossible to work with, only got the job because of her father, plastic surgery, botox addiction, contract cancelled soon") made up by the phony, self-styled experts and "plastic surgeons" and posted here and on Ms Cassidy's page.



~~~~~
Because supporting your thesis is tough, but throwing adjectives is easy.

reply

You're working on a flawed premise, that all the people that want her back now are the same ones that wanted her gone in the earlier seasons.


precisely. i can't BELIEVE the OP misses our whining about how obnoxious laurel is. even though, those of us who found her to be cringe-worthy, found her significantly LESS SO as black canary, to the point where our complaints were few and far between, the show is clearly superior without her. if the OP REALLY WANTS the last two weeks of the IMDB forum to be FULL of THANK G-D LAUREL'S GONE threads, we can do this for you. i hate to have you disappointed. no PROBS. you won't be able to FIND other thread on other topics through the flood of THIS SHOW IS FINALLY MAKING A COMEBACK and then hi! ho! laurel's dead, the witch is dead - she lost her head!

if that's what'll REALLY MAKE YOU HAPPY, say the word.

not enough words for DUH.

reply

I love it too. As a tried and true Laurel defender from the start ots nice to no longer have to work as hard.

reply

heh, yeah.


~~~~~
Because supporting your thesis is tough, but throwing adjectives is easy.

reply

I love it too. As a tried and true Laurel defender from the start ots nice to no longer have to work as hard.

That's the only positive thing about Laurel's death! Also, I feel happy for Katie Cassidy that she's finally free from the toxic cluster *beep* that is the "Arrow" fandom. I'm not talking about ALL fans of course (on either side), but about the peeps who seem to spend most of their fandom time monitoring the actors' social media to find things to "shade"/berate them for.

reply

I agree so much w/the OP; I have always been a huge supporter of Laurel since the VERY beginning starting w/season 1 and I have NEVER stopped giving her my support. Why now are people wanting Laurel's return especially the ones who spoke so derogatory about her all the time? Well, seems the message boards had a lot of problems on different television show message boards w/so many trolls that now they closing ALL message boards down. I wish way back in the very first season and then some people would've given Laurel a chance, the actress was just doing what the writers told her to do and Katie Cassidy did a wonderful job, I miss her presence on the screen. I have been a fan of Katie Cassidy since her days as Ruby on Supernatural (favorite show of mine) and she did so damn good as the demon Ruby and had such great chemistry w/the Winchester boys. I will say the writing for Laurel here on Arrow started to get a little sketchy but Cassidy handled it like a PRO she is and the writers decide to kill her off anyway. I REALLY wish you Laurel haters from back in the day who now support her would've spoke up much sooner. I think a lot of fans of the soap opera titled Olicity ruined this show, it made the Arrow weaker; I try my hardest to forget those days b/c that is when Oliver changed for the worst it was like his a "part" of his manhood was snipped off. Sorry so long... Laurel Lance aka Black Canary ROCKED !! I miss the REAL Laurel/Black Canary.

reply

I agree so much w/the OP; I have always been a huge supporter of Laurel since the VERY beginning starting w/season 1 and I have NEVER stopped giving her my support.


Ah, a kindred soul! I sometimes feel that if the Laurel fans (because they always existed, despite the "five Laurel stans" mantra) had been a little more proactive and promoted her/Katie Cassidy on social media the way the Felicity/Olicity/EBR fans promoted their girl from day one, she might not have been sidelined/killed off in season four. I guess we just rested on our laurels (pun!) because we had the delusionary belief that they would never kill of such a crucial character in the GA canon. This is pure speculation of course, and maybe Guggenheim just wanted to get rid of Laurel/KC, for whatever reason, which means that fan reception wouldn't have mattered anyway.

I just think it's sad that this skewed picture of Laurel as a total failure of a character and BC incarnation has become so entrenched, especially since I find the plots, characterization and overall acting to be much better in the earlier seasons, when she still played a central role. I think it was in the first ep of season four that I realized that the "Arrow" writers' room had been infiltrated/hijacked by a bunch of Olicity shippers, who thought that Desperate Housewife Oliver hiding rings in soufflés and making quips like "You have failed this omelet" was the way to Make Arrow Great! I honestly don't know if the show ever recovered from that total remake, no matter how desperately they're trying to recreate the season one vibe right now.

Anyway, it was interesting to read about your experiences after Katrina. There was a lot about Katrina in European media when it happened, but people forget that it's the aftermath/picking up the pieces that's the really hard part.

reply

[deleted]

Katie bathwater drinkers
hideos chin implant
nose implant
breasts implants

Now I know where Superles is hiding.

He never minded posting trash like this.



~~~~~
Because supporting your thesis is tough, but throwing adjectives is easy.

reply

I Like Laurel alot and was pissed they killed her off. I think they could have done so much with her. This coming from a Olicity / Felicity Fan!!

reply

I was never a Laurel fan, liked her sister much more. I wish Laurel went to Legends and Sara stayed at Arrow. I'm not interested in watching Legends.

Having said that, I liked Felicity at first much more until she became Oliver's thing.

reply