MovieChat Forums > Mob City (2013) Discussion > i hate period shows that try to be too '...

i hate period shows that try to be too 'pretty'...


One gripe i have whenever a television show attempts to recreate a period within the last 100 years is they always use new-looking clothes for all the characters, shiny restored vehicles for all the cars, clean and well-maintained streets and buildings for the sets, etc. The past was not ALL NEW AND SHINY AND CLEAN!!! This kind of approach derails a TV drama into fantasy territory rather than being taken seriously as a drama because, whether consciously picked-up by the audience or not, everything looks too "recreated" instead of authentic.

For instance, the first scene between Bernal and Simon Pegg in the jazz club--supposedly in a "colored" (lower-income) part of town looked as swanky as any club that might have been on the Sunset Strip. To me, it just stuck out as immediately unrealistic.

Did anyone watch the CBS series VEGAS that aired last year and was supposed to take place in Las Vegas in 1960? It suffered from the same case of "new-itis" that Mob City has, but you'd expect something like that from a show on American network TV. I was hoping a show on cable that Frank Darabont was calling the shots for would have avoided this pitfall.




. . . there's always room for Jello!

reply

[deleted]

Actually, the fact that Frank Darabont was going to be in charge of this show gave me more hope than any reservations I might have had about it being on TNT. Live and learn, i guess.



. . . there's always room for Jello!

reply

[deleted]

Well...I kinda enjoy American Horror Story, even though I don't think it's as great as all the critics seem to be blathering about. But you're right, there's not much else on in December, and I like film noir (even mediocre film noir), so I'll stick it out with Mob City.

Hey, here's a good new show i'd recommend: check out Les Revenants (The Returned) on the Sundance channel, it's pretty good.



. . . there's always room for Jello!

reply

its a new style for Frank, he probably wouldve been better off getting some help from terrance winter or tim van patten

reply

I understand the criticism. But, if they were determined to make it pretty, they hired a great cinematographer in David Tattersall!

"I. Drink. Your. Milkshake! [slurp!] I DRINK IT UP!" - Daniel Plainview - "There Will Be Blood"

reply

I'm liking this show, but I agree everyone/everything is so pretty and clean. I do love that they didn't the most beautiful people they could find. The characters fit the part.

My biggest gripe for periods pieces is the language. I haven't seen that so far with Mob City, other shows that don't use appropriate language for the time makes me crazy!

reply