MovieChat Forums > Holy Motors (2012) Discussion > Why is it that no matter how goofy or no...

Why is it that no matter how goofy or nonsensical a film is


It aways has its defenders? Holy Motors is not only avant-garde crap, but it's also really boring. I don't care if you think there's a deeper meaning to seeing a guy lick blood under Eva Mende's armpits, at the end of the day, if you can't make something intriguing to watch, what's the point of making a film?

I also find smoking in a film really annoying. It really has nothing to do with a character. Just a pet peeve of mine. It has moreso to do with the actor not being able to withold acting out on his disability than adding anything to his role.

reply

Andy Rooney is that you?

ce n'est pas une image juste, c'est juste une image

reply

It's funny that you wrote "if you can't make something intriguing to watch, what's the point of making a film?", wyntrz, because:

Number one: I personally found the film to be primarily INTRIGUING.

Number two: Because it didn't "intrigue" you, doesn't mean Leos Carax didn't have a point to make - or that he or anyone else shouldn't have made a film at all.

Number three: Not every film's raison d'etre is to "intrigue" you. I don't think that was the point of a TRANSFORMERS or a Jennifer Aniston movie, don't you?

Number four: The fact that you can have such a "point of view" about your viewing experience & I have mine & we are communicating it and it has made (at least) me ruminate about it & write this (feel free to disagree) is THE justification we need for films like this to be made. Or to get really "deep", this is one of the purposes of ART. Dialogue.

Number five: They say about art that it's a mirror. The mirror is on you. You "get" the movie in your own personal way. You ultimately get what you bring in.

Number Six: French director Catherine Breillat saw a newspaper headline asking about one of her films: Is It Pornography or Is It Art?
She replied: "If you have to ask that question, then it's Art".

Number seven: "I'm not mad at you. I'm mad at the dirt". - Faye Dunaway as Joan Crawford in MOMMIE DEAREST.

Have a nice day.

;)


reply

To each his or her own. I found this film far from boring. Tree of Life, now that was boring (except the dinosaur part).

--------
See a list of my favourite films here: http://www.flickchart.com/slackerinc

reply

Isn't smoking still a cultural thing in France?

HI F-ING YA
Nicholas Cage Deadfall
2013 Rankings imdb.com/list/2-zx4cThbEY/

reply

Loved this movie, I was entertained all along.
Not a single moment of boredom.

reply