MovieChat Forums > Jodaeiye Nader az Simin (2011) Discussion > Why did tutor change her testimony? Who...

Why did tutor change her testimony? Who took the money?


Did the tutor change her testimony because Nader frightened her by coming alongside her car?
Did she feel threatened by that action? Before that, she was so firm in her convictions.

Who took the money that was missing from the house? Was it the caregiver or merely mislaid?

Why didn't Nader insist the caregiver give the name of the doctor she consulted when she left the father alone? (The young daughter had mentioned that.) If the gyn testified that she had miscarried already before the "pushing" incident, then the case would have been over.

reply


Who took the money that was missing from the house? Was it the caregiver or merely mislaid?

The wife. They show at the beginning, the movers were charging more than she expected, so she went into that room and took more money out.

Why didn't Nader insist the caregiver give the name of the doctor she consulted when she left the father alone? (The young daughter had mentioned that.) If the gyn testified that she had miscarried already before the "pushing" incident, then the case would have been over.

But she hadn't miscarried before the pushing incident. She was hurt from being hit by the car, but she had not miscarried. The miscarriage happened after the incident where Nader made her leave. That's why she was in the hospital that night.


You must be the change you seek in the world. -- Gandhi

reply


<<Did the tutor change her testimony because Nader frightened her by coming alongside her car?
Did she feel threatened by that action? Before that, she was so firm in her convictions. >>

No. She wasn't afraid of anything. She just found out that he was lying about not hearing the tutor and Razieh speaking about the pregnancy and he was lying that he didn't know that Razieh was pregnant.

Well, how did she find out that he was lying?
If you remember Nader called her and ask for the number of the doctor that tutor gave to Razieh. So this means that he heard the speaking about pregnancy. Bcoz at the same time that Razieh and tutor talked about pregnancy, the tutor gave the number of the doctor to Razieh.
If you remember, Termeh found out that her father is lying in the same way and she said that to her father.

reply