This is an interesting scene, I like the idea one poster had about it depicting the old versus the new. The old must give in to the new and the old are at the new's mercy. Comic relief was another idea but I thought perhaps it was to show that the senior, although afflicted with Alzheimer's, could still be very aware of his surroundings and what was going on. He seemed alarmed at what the child was doing and was aware enough to be able to portray some humour about it in the way he smiled and engaged with her a bit through his eye contact and facial expressions. Or maybe it was just fear and he was trying to distract her from doing it again. But he was at his most aware while doing it. Was it to show that despite his affliction he didn't want to die? We see that he is alarmed at the idea that she could kill him with her actions. Maybe it was to make him seem more human to us. To portray that many afflicted people still have a strong instinct or desire to live. A few other times I saw a real sadness and understanding in his facial expressions that showed he had a deeper understanding of what was going on than we first may have thought. (That was one of many things I loved about this movie, the facial expressions, the incredible acting that let you forget it was acting, even from the teenager and child.). Another reason for the scene may have been to show the power youth has over the aged. He was completely at this child's mercy while she was unwatched and fooling around with the valve. The loss of power the aged must eventually accept and give up to the young. And that the young can seem almost heartless and unaware of their strength, health, and power over the weak and aged. (Also depicted by the child playing with the wheelchair.)
When you get up in the morning, how do you decide what shade of black to wear? (Shallow Grave)
reply
share