Who agrees with me?

I liked the story of the first and second ones better than Infinite. It was engaging, but also confusing and it lacked a lot of the elements found in the other games.

For example, the biggest theme from the first 2 games were the choices. In the second one you were a Big Daddy. You could choose to be a monster that kills everything, or you could be a compassionate guardian that cares for the little sisters.

Same with the first one, you could choose to help the little girls, or you could kill them instead.

Infinite offered choices, but in the end the game kind of ended the same way no matter what you do.

This version of the game wasn't very scary either. The other two had very creepy elements and I remembered jumping a couple times when the slicers came up from behind me. This was missing in this game.