MovieChat Forums > BioShock Infinite (2013) Discussion > Theoretical tie-in with Bioshock origina...

Theoretical tie-in with Bioshock original SPOILERS


Booker DeWitt feels guilt over the Wounded Knee battle and gets baptized and splits into 2 universes: One where he remains Booker DeWitt and one where he reinvents himself as Zachary Comstock, as the baptism made him mad and he saw the angel Columbia speak to him. The one where he avoids baptism he remains Booker and has a daughter and builds up a lot of gambling debt and sells his daughter to pay off the debt...? So far so good, right?

He's already feeling guilt over Wounded Knee and now he's practically suicidal over selling his daughter, meanwhile his other reality (Comstock) goes on to meet the Lucedes(sp?) and build Columbia. Through the technology that creates Columbia, they discover that Comstock becomes sterile and cannot have children, so he essentially takes her from Booker who does not deserve her, since he would sell her to begin with. Therefore, no version of this man is any good for Elizabeth; save that Booker DeWitt has remorse and Comstock does not. The Lucedes(sp?) decide to help Booker the way they helped Comstock, however Comstock betrayed and killed them, so now they want some retribution and they use their technology to bring Booker into Comstock's reality to hunt him down and save the girl. Here we get to the gooey chewy center:

DeWitt hated war and what he had done in that war. Baptism was not a solution (is my belief) and this drove DeWitt mad and to justify his baptism as a solution he hallucinated an angel named Columbia telling him to build the city. His own alternate self hunted him down and killed him. Now Booker returns to the notion of baptism with Elizabeth after he sees that religion and prejudice are evil and still lead to war. The Elizabeths "baptize" him and THINK they kill him, but instead he is only in a coma (unconscious). He wakes up and now has a hatred of religion and government.....

He reinvents himself again and now changes his name to Andrew Ryan. With all the VIGORS in his system he ages slower and REbecomes another type like Comstock and creates a city to escape religion and government in RAPTURE. Besides, he already has the idea from see Rapture through Elizabeth's tear.

I like wearing camoflage; it helps me hide... coffee stains.

reply

It is a very good theory and one that has alot of good similarities with the original Bioshock.

Ryan=Comstock
Jack=Booker Dewitt
Little Sisters/Big Daddies= Elizabeth/SongBird

They are all technically related to one another

"Theres is always a lighthouse, a man, and a city"

For all we know this could be in an upcoming DLC pack, where we could be in a different City with a different lighthouse, a different man, and a different city. Constants and variables......

For a Good Laugh call 985-655-2500

reply

Thanks for responding JWags. You are so right... perhaps it was NO coincidence that they included original Bioshock on the disc for future DLC access to RAPTURE!! We'll see I guess.

I like wearing camoflage; it helps me hide... coffee stains.

reply

BTW, I know everyone noticed there was still one version of Elizabeth left when they "killed" Booker/Comstock. Implying further that Booker yet lives and may go on like I thought.

I like wearing camoflage; it helps me hide... coffee stains.

reply

Also after all the credits rolled, you are booker in the office and you see if Anna is still in the other room.

maybe this is the booker who didnt sell anna, because you still see his gambling markers on the desk. I wonder if we will see him again?

For a Good Laugh call 985-655-2500

reply

That boy the Vox Populi woman nearly kills would have a greater likelihood to turn out to be Ryan

But I doubt even that. Occam's Razor may be in play here, and youre making it more complex than need be. They DO make a point of multiple timelines. So Elizabeth and Booker's visit to Rapture is likely to be the sole connection Infinate has with the first two Bioshocks, and is there solely to illustrate the plot point of parallel universes.

And it's possible that might not even BE the Rapture of the first two Bioshocks. Some have pointed out that the placement of the dead Big Daddy and Little Sister seen in the background of Songbird's death might be incongruous with the first games plot. I dont know. But its been postulated.

But long story short, I just dont see Ryan being Booker. It's too much of a stretch.

reply