Why Willem? Why?


Easily one of his worst performances, I almost can't blame him. He obviously owed someone a favor or, at the very least, was picturing a different product. Aside from the fact that almost no research seemed to have been done on tracking, Dafoe never comes close to playing the part. What bothered me most is, here is a lifelong loner, a hired gun, mercenary and within 30 minutes, he's so attached to this strange family, he can't stand to be away. Aside from the ridiculous plot, the character development all goes south in the final 25 minutes. Neill goes from being the ominous shady character that is tracking the tracker, to the weepy, nobody understands what I stand for loner. The mistake filled movie then decides to have the worst and in many ways, most predictable ending possible, but instead of leaving the audience with a sense of wonder, it not only displays it, it drags it out for every pretentious second it can. When it's over, you breathe a sigh of relief and then they actually "go there." I love Dafoe, I like Neill and O'Connor is a solid actress when she actually gets a role, but this was a mess.

reply

Totally disagree. I thought it was a fine performance, as most of his work always is. He's forced by circumstances to stay in the house Redleaf via Jack Mindy have organised for him. Early on, we see him try to get a hotel room but is refused. The relationship with the family builds up right through the film, not just in the first 30 minutes and I liked the way Martin slowly warmed, first to the children, then later to Lucy.

Yes, Jack is a kind of Redleaf sub-contractor, but we find that he also has links with the local loggers, but also has a soft spot for the family as well. Big deal in a small town? I don't think so.

The mistake filled movie ... decides to have the worst ... most predictable ending possible ...
That's your opinion. I thought the producers constructed the conclusion to fit with present day realities concerning the tiger's existence or otherwise and perhaps to be consistent with the novel. It sounds like you were hoping for more of a Disney outcome which was always going to be unlikely in a film of this nature.🐭

reply

[deleted]

Absolute unadulterated crap. Willem Dafoe was fantastic. A film full of depth, intelligence and beauty, quite rare these days.

reply