MovieChat Forums > The Dark Tower (2017) Discussion > A refreshing surprise that will defy boo...

A refreshing surprise that will defy book readers' expectations


Wow: that leaked trailer really has confirmed all the hopes I had for this project.

Thanks to the Horn of Eld (and Akiva Goldsman's genius) the film discards most of the boring storyline and redundant characters from the Dark Tower and puts much more emphasis on the characters and story arc that REALLY matter. I'm simply grateful we'll get a Dark Tower adaptation which will be so wonderfully different from what book readers imagined (it's so nice when you get surprised!).

And with each new casting announcement I felt like jubilating:

Abbey Lee plays Tirana. God I'm so excited! Genius writer Akiva Goldsman has realized how important Tirana is. Tirana practically IS The Dark Tower - I hope she will be in every scene (which is now possible because: THE HORN OF ELD).

Jackie Earle Haley plays the third most important character (after Roland and the Man in Black): Richard Sayre! The character is actually important enough to warrant his own movie (maybe in a future spin-off? THE HORN OF ELD could make it possible).

And now, finally, after months of feverish anticipation, it has been announced that Fran Kranz will play Pimli, another key character and fan favorite whose role was thankfully enhanced in Goldsman's fantastic screenplay.

But it doesn't end there; few knew but millions speculated who would play one of the most pivotal roles in the The Dark Tower multiverse: Arra. Now it has finally been revealed that none other than Claudia Kim will portray this wonderfully compelling character.

And, at the very last, fan favorites Dr Hotchkiss and Timmy also have been cast.

Akiva Goldsman really is a mastermind of cinema: it's almost as if he was able to see into King's mind and extract the writer's true vision for the Dark Tower (which King sadly failed to put on the page). Using the HORN OF ELD to achieve this was a master stroke.

And there's more changes for the better: in the books, the Man in Black is a looming presence, but he only very rarely physically appears. But instead of a weird (and boooooring) mythical, mysterious creature, isn't it much nicer to actually have him as a physical antagonist that shows up all the time and doesn't force you to use your imagination? And now the Man in Black even has a sidekick - isn't that great?

Man, that Horn sure changed everything for the better, and it's so nice to see that it was all it took to make the fans come around and embrace Akiva's vision. I can hardly wait: this adaptation is already a success in any reader's book (so much so they don't even really need to film it anymore).



http://www.the-fanboy-perspective.com/a-rant-against-modern-tentpole-film-making.html

reply

*cough* *cough*
And then everyone clapped.

The man in black fled across the desert and the gunslinger followed.

reply

*cough* *cough*
And then everyone clapped.

A little touch of the flu obviously didn't keep everyone from appreciating the truth. The applause is well deserved.👏👏👏

"The complication had a little complication."

reply

Tirana IS the dark tower? She was as minor a character in the book as there could be. Are you sure you're thinking of the right person?

reply

I just released your post and got the sarcasm...

reply

I just released your post and got the sarcasm...

Sarcasm? Where? When? Surely not from me. I'm Akiva Goldsman's most devoted fan (I even own a signed copy of his original script for 'Batman & Robin').

"The complication had a little complication."

reply

Just like the faithfully true Under the Dome adaptation, that understood better than king what the real story was all along. I can't wait to see the pilot from Prometheus blast his way through each action set piece!

reply

👍

reply

The OP has forgotten the face of his father. Someone just shoot him please.

4 8 15 16 23 42

reply

The OP has forgotten the face of his father. Someone just shoot him please.

Long days and pleasant nights to you too, sai.

You might want to read that post again before wishing capital punishment on me.

Thankee sai.

"The complication had a little complication."

reply

My bad, thought you were serious!

Long days and pleasant nights to you too, sai.

4 8 15 16 23 42

reply

No harm done. Your heart was clearly in the right place.

Cheers, 

"The complication had a little complication."

reply



"The complication had a little complication."

reply



"The complication had a little complication."

reply

I'm glad I wasn't drinking anything while reading this. Thanks for the giggles 😊

reply



"The complication had a little complication."

reply

GENIUS...I lol'd

You had me sucked in 100%

I'm still greatly looking forward to the movie though!

reply

I'm still greatly looking forward to the movie though!
Which is perfectly fine.

Btw, what did you think of the trailer?

http://www.the-fanboy-perspective.com/a-rant-against-modern-tentpole-film-making.html

reply