MovieChat Forums > In Time (2011) Discussion > Why are the Timekeepers so underpaid?

Why are the Timekeepers so underpaid?


This is just one particular point I felt like raising because, while there are plenty of plotholes and badly written parts in the movie (as in most others, for that matter) the movie specifically went out of its way to tell us how the Timekeepers are scandalously underpaid. Why is that, though? This is a dictatorship which relies on state power to repress a vast number of impoverished, disenfranchised people. It does not make sense anyway. The Timekeepers should be paid well so that they have an incentive to actually do their jobs. They should also be paid well to ensure their loyalty. I mean, come on! If the military is paid similarly, then there should have been a military coup long ago!

It's also extremely impractical. Raymond had to choose between chasing down Will or collecting his daily wages. I'm sure this is not the first time this has happened. Very inefficient! It's not just when you suddenly need to chase someone that this becomes an issue. Imagine a hostage negotiation scenario... or, for that matter, imagine what happens if the Timekeeper's car is stolen/damaged while he is in a remote location, or any number of other situations.

If I were the dictator of this society, I'd make it so that Timekeepers are well-paid and it's one of the most lucrative jobs available (same for the military), while legally or de facto ensuring that they can only come from Zones 1-3 or so (so they don't feel empathy with the poor in the lower districts). Also, rigorous indoctrination and testing, of course. Though it's quite interesting how Raymond, someone who came from a poor background, was one of the most zealous Timekeepers around. Such a shame that we didn't find out much of his background after all, it was a really interesting plot point that should have been developed more. Better yet, just disable the damn time mechanism for the Timekeepers, or if that's not possible, always give them a week every time they go below one week. And for science's sake, make it harder to steal the damn time!

reply

imagine what happens if the Timekeeper's car is stolen/damaged while he is in a remote location, or any number of other situations.


This is why Will gave him time when Sylvia shot him.



make it harder to steal the damn time!


Absolutely.


I agree it would have been intersting to learn more about Raymond Leon.




Will Graham: I don't find you that interesting.
Hannibal Lecter: You will.

reply

The movie hints that he might have been a bit unusual in that he had a tendency to cut it close with regard to receiving his daily allocation. it migt have somehig to do with the fact that he used to be a district 12 citizen himself, and he keeps himself on a low time to bring an urgency to his work.

I can think of 2 reasons why those in power would not want time keepers to be paid too much. For one thing this allows the rich to control them. If they get uppity, then just cancel their per diem. Also it makes them susceptible to bribery.

reply

They can't really be bribed, everyone noticed immediatley when Will gave some, very little time to Ray.

I think the real reason is that they had to go into ghettos, so they couldn't have much time on their hands to avoid being robbed by a mob.

reply

to keep them on the short leash, beside the rich people, the time keepers are the ones that truly understand how the time economy works and what are the weaknesses, they're given small amount of time so they don't have enough time currency to educate the lower classes about the nature of the economy and incite/bribe the lower classes into rebellions.

reply

What I liked about this movie is that it comments and reflects our own society. At least part of the point of their low wages is surely to reflect how essential services in our world are not especially high paid jobs - in the UK police, nurses, firemen, soldiers are not by any means wealthy, yet do essential jobs in protecting the rich and the society structures which maintain inequalities.

reply

Raymond actually explains it when Will looks at his arm and sees there isn't much time on it. He says it's to prevent being robbed

reply