Not as bad
as most "critics" say. All these whiners, complaining about too much cgi are no real critics. WT_ did you expect? It's a movie by Emmerich. It's Independence Day for _'s sake. If you did expect a deep story, drama and political topics you should have known better and should better write about something else or better, stop writing at all.
Yes, the dialogs are cheesy and it's sometimes near slapstick. But as i said, it's not Kafka, it's Independence Day!
Another example how "metacritic" is mainly wirtten by snobs.